The 7 Years War: The World Catches Fire (Part 2)
- Published
- Duration
- 47:52
On a cold Sunday in March 1757, Admiral John Byng knelt on a cushion on the quarterdeck of a ship in Portsmouth harbour, dropped a handkerchief, and was shot by a platoon of Royal Marines while the entire fleet watched. He had thirty-nine years of service. His crime was failing to try hard enough. Voltaire got the line that stuck: in this country it is thought well to kill an admiral from time to time, to encourage the others.
That is what Britain looked like in 1757. Losing, frightened, and looking for someone to blame.
Three years later it was winning everywhere on earth at once, so relentlessly that Horace Walpole complained the church bells of London had been worn threadbare ringing for victories.
This episode is how that happened. Every alliance in Europe reverses itself in four months. A Prussian king who wrote bad French poetry and carried opium in his pocket is attacked by France, Austria, Russia and Sweden simultaneously, and in five weeks fights two battles that build a national myth still doing damage in 1914. An East India Company officer with no military training wins a battle in Bengal mostly by bribing the opposing general, and hands a corporation an empire. And a politician who is vain, unstable, frequently bedridden and completely right works out the strategy that wins the whole war.
It ends above Quebec in September 1759, with two generals dying within hours of each other on the same field, and with Britain holding a victory it cannot afford.
Part two of three.
Got a topic you want covered, or thoughts on the show? Email us at [email protected] — we read everything. And if you're enjoying Double Helix, a rating or review genuinely helps new listeners find us.
More episodes at historyhelix.podview.com.
Have feedback? Send us a Text and Interact with us!
Alitu- Podcasting made easierJoin Alitu. With easy to use tool and intuitive processes, you will be podcasting in no time
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.
Website: https://historyhelix.podview.com/
Twitter: @HistoryHelix
BlueSky: @historyhelix.bsky.social
Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Doublehelixhistory
Instagram: History_Helix
Email: [email protected]
An Admiral Faces The Firing Squad
SPEAKER_01: Portsmouth Harbor is full of ships, and every one of them has sent men to watch. The decks of the fleet are crowded. Boats have come out from the shore and are holding at a distance, full of civilians who wrote out for this. Nobody's talking much. It is the 14th of March of 1757. It is a cold Sunday morning, and what is about to happen on this quarter deck has never happened before in the history of the Royal Navy.
SPEAKER_01: An Admiral is brought up from below. He's 52 years old. He's wearing a plain gray coat and a white waistcoat. No decorations. Nothing that marks his rank. He has been a serving officer since he was thirteen. His father was an admiral before him. One of the most celebrated in the service. And he grew up inside the Navy the way other men grow up inside a family business. A cushion is placed on the deck for him to kneel on. A platoon of Royal Marines is drawn up nine paces away.
SPEAKER_01: First, he's offered a chair. He declines it. Then he's offered a blindfold. He declines that too. One of the officers press and explains, quietly, that the Marines may not be able to do it if he looks at them. Thinks about this and accepts to blindfold.
SPEAKER_01: He kneels down on the cushion. He has a handkerchief in his right hand. He has been told that when he drops it, they will fire.
SPEAKER_01: He holds it to the side. He's holding it for a long time.
SPEAKER_01: His name was John Bing. He was an admiral of the Royal Navy. He was executed by his own service for failing to try hard enough. Three years later, a French writer put the incident in a novel that half of Europe read and gave it the line it has carried ever since. In this country, it is taught well to kill an admiral from time to time in order to encourage the others.
Britain Panics Into Total War
SPEAKER_01: You know how they say you can't understand someone until you walk a mile in their shoes? Well, I'd argue you can't understand a nation until you've walked through its history. Not just to highlight Rio or the sanitized version you find in textbooks. I mean really getting into its DNA. Those defining moments that shaped everything that came after. Those moments where paths were chosen, where decisions were made in palaces and backrooms and city streets that changed the course of millions of lives.
SPEAKER_01: I'm your host, Paul, and this is Double Helix, Blueprint of Nations, where we unravel the genetic code of countries through their most transformative moments. Think of it like ancestry testing, but for entire nations. We dig deep into the historical DNA, finding those crucial moments that made countries who they are today.
SPEAKER_01: What you just heard is what a country does to a man with 39 years of service when it is frightened enough. And frightened is the word. The thing to know about Britain in the spring of 1756 is that it is losing. Britain is a rich trading nation with a superb navy and a small but unimpressive army. It has spent two years being beaten in the American woods. It is about to lose a Mediterranean island as well. There is genuine fear of a French landing on the south coast. The government is unstable and knows it.
SPEAKER_00: And its answer to that first real defeat is to find an officer to land and shoot him in front of the entire fleet.
SPEAKER_00: Three years later, that same country will win on every continent and fight on all at once.
SPEAKER_00: And there are four places we need to be on to travel in.
SPEAKER_01: All of this happens inside four years. Which is really the point of the whole episode. This is the first war in history where something decided in one hemisphere gets somebody killed on the other side before the season is out.
SPEAKER_00: At the end of it all, Britain wins. That's not the spoiler.
SPEAKER_01: What I ask you to watch for is what it costs.
SPEAKER_00: Because the bill for this whole enterprise is due in the next episode.
SPEAKER_01: For now, we start in Vienna with a man quietly rearranging Europe.
SPEAKER_01: The men rearranging Europe is called Wenzel Anton von Kaunitz.
Kaunitz Engineers A New Alliance
SPEAKER_01: He is the Austrian state chancellor. He is a hypochondric who travels with his own doctor and cannot tolerate droughts, and he is probably the most effective diplomat of the 18th century. He has one objective, which he has been pursuing patiently for years, and which he has convinced his empress to pursue with him. He wants Tilicia back. Tilicia is a rich province, heavily industrial by the standards of the day, with about a million people in it, and until 1740, it belonged to Austria. Then, a 28-year-old who had just inherited the throne of Prussia marched in and took it, without warning, without a declaration, and without any legal claim worth the name.
SPEAKER_01: His name was Frederick. Maria Theresa, the Empress of Austria, fought two wars trying to get it back and failed both times. And she has never for one second stopped wanting it back. She referred to Frederick, in private and occasionally not in private, as that evil man and the monster.
SPEAKER_01: So Kaunitz sits down and works through the problem like an engineer. First, Austria cannot beat Prussia alone. It has tribe. Austria's traditional ally is Britain. And Britain is useless for this purpose. Because Britain's continental interest is protecting Hanover, and Britain will never underwrite a war of conquest in Silicia. So the traditional alliance is worthless. Therefore, Kaunitz concludes, Austria needs a neo ally. The neo ally needs to be France.
SPEAKER_01: Now, Austria and France have been enemies for 250 years. Habsburg against Bourbon is the oldest quarrel in European royal dynamics and politics. The organizing fact of the continent since the days of Charles V. Suggesting an Austrian alliance with France in 1750 is like suggesting a cat form a partnership with a dog for tax purposes. It's not that people think it's a bad idea, it's that the category does not even exist. Kaunitz spends five years making the category exist. And here's where the story acquires one of its strangest figures.
SPEAKER_01: Because the route into the French court runs through a lady called Madame de Pompadour. Madame de Pompadour is Louis XV's former mistress, and by this point, something more like his chief of staff, a woman of real political ability in a court that despises her for being common-born. Kaunitz makes a point of treating her as a legitimate political actor, which almost nobody in Versailles does. Frederick of Prussia, meanwhile, has been writing mocking verses about her, which get repeated as mocking verses always do.
SPEAKER_01: Frederick has also been writing mocking things about Empress Elizabeth of Prussia. This also gets repeated. I want to be careful not to overstate this, because serious state interests drove all three of these powers towards each other regardless. But it is a genuine fact of the record that Frederick the Great, who thought of himself as the cleverest man in Europe, spent the 1750s personally insulting two of the three women who would shortly form a coalition to destroy him. And that both of them remembered it 5.56, Britain and Prussia signed the Convention of Westminster.
SPEAKER_01: It is a limited defensive thing. Britain wants Hanover protected, and Frederick wants one fewer enemy, so they agree to keep foreign armies out of Germany.
Frederick’s Gamble And Prussia’s Myth
SPEAKER_01: Frederick thinks he has been clever. He has just neutralized Britain as an enemy at essentially no cost. What he has actually done is hand counted the last piece of the puzzle. Because France reached the convention of Westminster as betrayal. Prussia has been France's client. Now Prussia has made a deal with France's enemy.
SPEAKER_01: And on the first of May 1756, France and Austria signed the first treaty of Versailles.
SPEAKER_01: And an empress who takes Frederick personally comes in alongside Sweden, we'll follow later. Britain and France declare war in each other in the same way.
SPEAKER_01: On one side, France, Russia, Sweden, and most of the smaller German states. On the other, Russia and Britain. Frederick is now surrounded by three great powers who have agreed that he should not exist.
SPEAKER_01: And while all this is happening, France opens the war by doing the one thing Britain is least prepared for. In April, it lands 15,000 men on Menorca, the British naval base in the western Mediterranean. The garrison holds out in Fort St. Philip, London, sends a relief fleet under Admiral John Bing. But the fleet is late, underman, with ships in poor repair, which is the Admiralty's fault and not his. On the 20th of May, he fights an inconclusive action against a French fleet of roughly equal strength, takes damage, holds a council of war with his captains, and concludes that he cannot relieve the garrison and should preserve his fleet for the defense of Gibraltar.
SPEAKER_01: He withdraws. Menorca falls at the end of June.
SPEAKER_01: Britain loses its mind. There is rioting. Bing is burned in effigy in towns that could not find Menorca on a map. The government, which is deeply unpopular and knows perfectly well that it sent him out with inadequate force, discovers that it has a way to avoid the blame and takes it. Bing is court-martialed. The court acquits him of cowardice and disaffection, which were the serious charges. However, it convicts him of failing to do his utmost. And under the Articles of War, as amended seven years earlier, there's exactly one sentence available for that offense, and the court has no discretion whatsoever.
SPEAKER_01: In fact, the officers who convicted him immediately and unanimously petitioned for mercy. But the king refused.
SPEAKER_01: Bing wrote a short statement the night before and handed it to the marshals on the quarter deck. The statement ends like this.
SPEAKER_01: Unfortunately for Bing, he was wrong about that for about 200 years.
SPEAKER_01: Everything Britain does for the rest of this war is done by an establishment that has just demonstrated in public with a firing squad that failure will not be survivable. You can read the ferocity of the next four years as either strategic brilliance, and a lot of it was, or you can also read it as an empire that has panicked and has frightened itself into greatness.
SPEAKER_01: Let me take you into a room at Saint-Suci, because the man in it does not fit the story that he's about to become.
SPEAKER_01: He is 44, he has no children and no interest in having any. He plays the flute well enough to have written concertos for it that are still performed. He's playing one now.
SPEAKER_01: He's also, at this moment, planning to invade a neutral country. The men is Frederick II of Prussia. He is genuinely a strange figure, and I think the strangeness is the interesting part. He's an intellectual who despises intellectuals in government. He wrote a book, Attacking Machiavelli, published it the year he took the throne, and then spent the next 40 years acting like the most attentive student Machiavelli ever had. He is capable of extraordinary cruelty towards his own soldiers and extraordinary sentimentality about his dogs who are buried beside him at his own instruction.
SPEAKER_01: But here's the problem, and it is a real one. Prussia in 1756 has about four and a half million people. France has 24 million. Austria around 18. Russia has more than that. Prussia's territory is scattered across northern Germany, in disconnected pieces with no natural frontiers, no mountains, no significant rivers in the right places, nothing that stops an army. What it has instead is an army of 850,000 men in a state that can barely afford it, drilled to a standard nobody else in Europe can match, and a treasury his father spent a lifetime filling.
SPEAKER_01: Against a coalition of three great powers, he cannot win a long war, and he knows it. Everything he does from here follows from that one piece of arithmetic. He must hit first, hit hard, and force somebody out of the coalition before the numbers grind him down.
SPEAKER_01: So at the end of August 1756, he invades Saxony, which is neutral, which does not threaten him, and which is in the way. It is an act of naked aggression, and it is condemned across Europe as exactly that, but it also works in a narrow sense. He takes Saxony's army, its treasury, and its resources, and he uses them to fund the next six years of war. And it hands his enemies the one thing they were missing, which is a moral case. The Holy Roman Empire declares against him, the coalition tightens.
SPEAKER_01: Then, in June 1757, he loses. At Kollin in Bohemia, he attacks an Austrian army in a strong position and it goes badly wrong. He loses roughly a third of his force. It is his first defeat in a pitch battle. There's a story, probably invented later, that as his guards falter, he shouted at them, asking whether they wanted to live forever. It is a wonderful line that I would not put money on him, have it said. What is certain is that by the autumn of 1757, Frederick is finished. A French army is coming at him from the west, an Austrian army is coming from the south.
SPEAKER_01: The Russians have beaten a Prussian force in East Prussia. Berlin has been briefly raided. He writes to his sister in terms that are not those of a man expecting to survive, and he has begun carrying opium pills in a small container on his person, which he mentions to correspondents with a calm that genuinely unsettles those who read it. And then in five weeks, he fights the two battles that make his reputation permanent.
SPEAKER_01: At Rochbach, he has about 22,000 men. Coming at him is a combined French and Imperial army of roughly 42,000, which believes it is about to trap him. What follows takes about 90 minutes. The Allied army attempts a wide flanking march around the Prussian position. It is a reasonable plan executed by an army with a divided command in the open, in full view. Frederick watches them do it, works out where they'll arrive, and moves his entire force behind a line of low hills to meet them there. The Allies come around the corner expecting to find a flank and instead walk into a foreign Prussian army, artillery already sighted, with Prussian cavalry under a commander named Seitlitz already in motion against their lead.
SPEAKER_01: The Allied army does not so much as lose as it disintegrates. Prussian losses are somewhere around 500. Allied losses are something like 10,000, most of them prisoners. It is one of the most loop-sided results in the history of European warfare, and it is inflicted by an army outnumbered two to one. Five weeks later, he is four hundred miles away in Silesia in winter, facing an Austrian army roughly twice his size that has just taken Breslau.
SPEAKER_01: Let me take you into the room the night before he marches. He has his senior officers assembled, and what he says to them is recorded closely enough that we can follow it. I shall attack the army of the enemy, whatever its position with my whole force. Then the turns. Any regiment of cavalry which does not charge home will be dismounted immediately after the battle. Any infantry battalion which begins to waver will lose his collars and his swords. And then to a room of men he has commanded for 17 years.
SPEAKER_01: Gentlemen, farewell. Shortly, we shall have bitten the enemy, we shall see each other no more.
SPEAKER_01: Two days later, at Leuten, he takes about 36,000 men against 66,000 Austrians, and he does something that people Have studied ever since. Uses the ground. There is a low ridge across the front, and he marches his army behind it in column, out of sight, past the Austrian center, and reassembles on the Austrian left flank, which is the weak end of the line. The Austrian commander sees movement, concludes the Prussians are retreating and begins to relax. Then the entire Prussian army appears at the right angles to his line in Echelon and rolls it up from the end.
SPEAKER_01: Napoleon, who was not a generous man about other generals, wrote that Leuten was a masterpiece of movements, maneuvers, and resolution, and that it alone was enough to place Frederick in the first rank of commanders.
SPEAKER_01: Now, here's the part that matters for this show. Militarily, Rosbach and Leuten do not win the war. Frederick is still surrounded. He will be beaten badly at Hochkirch and the following year. And in August of 1759, at Kunersdorf, he will lose so catastrophically that he writes this the same night. I have no more resources, and to tell the truth, I believe all is lost. I shall not survive the ruin of my country.
SPEAKER_01: However, what those five weeks do is create a story. The story is that Prussia is a small, poor, outnumbered state that survives because its army is better and its will is harder than anyone else's. That being surrounded by enemies is Prussia's permanent condition. That the correct response to overwhelming odds is to attack and to attack immediately. While this story is not entirely false, which is what makes it dangerous, it gets taught in Prussian and then German military academies for the next century and a half.
SPEAKER_01: It becomes the emotional foundation of an officer corps. And when the German general staff sits down in the early 1900s to plan for a war against France and Russia at the same time, the assumption underneath this whole plan is that a smaller, better army, surrounded by enemies, should strike first and strike hard, because that is what worked in 1757. Frederick survived his encirclement, partly through genuine brilliance and partly, as we'll see next episode, through one of the luckiest accidents in military history.
SPEAKER_01: The lesson Germany and Germans took from it left out the luck.
Bengal And The Company’s Coup
SPEAKER_01: Six thousand miles away, in the same month that Britain and France declare war, a completely separate quarrel turns into part of the same conflict.
SPEAKER_01: Bengal in 1756 is the richest province of the Mughal Empire. By some estimates, one of the wealthiest places on earth at the time.
SPEAKER_01: And along its rivers stood trading stations belonging to the English East India Company and the French company de Inf, both of which have been quietly fortified, both of which have private armies, and neither of which is supposed to have either. In 1756, a new no wife takes power.
SPEAKER_01: It's about 23 he inherited from his grandfather, and he is in a weak position with his own ability. Several of them will prefer somebody else. He orders both European companies to stop fortifying. The French complied. The English, however, do not. So in June, he marches on Calcutta with an army and takes each other. But then something happens that has been argued about over time. A number of English prisoners are confined overnight in a small punishment cell inside the fort in June at Bengal, and many of them die of heat and suffocation.
SPEAKER_01: The principal account comes from John Howell, a company official who was among the survivors, who claimed 146 men were put in and only 23 came out. Howell's numbers did not survive food. The cell was not large enough, and the role of company personnel in Calcutta does not support a figure that high. Modern estimates run closer to 64 confined and about 21 surviving, which is still a horrifying thing to have happen to people. Howell was also, by the time he wrote, a man with a strong interest in justifying what the company did next.
SPEAKER_01: And he was writing for an audience in London that wanted to be outraged. Something genuinely terrible did happen. The scale though was inflated, and the inflated version became one of the most effective pieces of imperial propaganda for the century. All three of these things are true, and if you only hold one of them, you got the story wrong. In January to June of 1757, the company sends a force from Madras to retake Calcutta, and in command of the military force is a 31-year-old named Robert Clive.
SPEAKER_01: Clive's background is worth a sentence, because it explains a lot. He came out to India as a clerk on a company writer's salary, hated it, tried to kill himself, according to a story he told himself, and then discovered during the wars against the French in southern India that he was extremely good at soldiering. He had no formal military training whatsoever, but he was aggressive, insubordinate, physically brave, and entirely uninterested in the distinction between his employer's interests and his own.
SPEAKER_01: He retakes Calcutta in January of 1757. Then he retakes the French settlement at Chandernagore, which turns a Bengali quarrel into a theater of European war. And then he does the thing that actually matters, which has nothing to do with fighting.
SPEAKER_01: Let me take you into that negotiation. It is the single most consequential conversation of the century, and it happened in rooms, on paper, between men who were all lying to each other.
SPEAKER_01: Clive opens secret talks with a faction of the Nawad's own court. The key figure is Mir Jafar, the commander of Nawat's army. The deal on the table is pretty straightforward. Mir Jafar's troops will not fight. In exchange, Mir Jafar becomes Nawat, and the company receives an enormous payment, and the individuals involved receive enormous personal payments on top of that. There's a second layer of deceit involving a Bengali financier named Omichunt, who threatens to expose the plot unless he gets a larger share, and a forged treaty Clive has drawn up to string him along with a false signature on it.
SPEAKER_01: Clive later defended the forgery in front of Parliament without much apparent embarrassment. The battle itself is almost anticlimatic. That is the point. Clive has about 3,000 men, of whom roughly 2,000 are Indian sitboys in company service. The Nawat has something like 50,000 plus French artillerymen. It rains. The Nawat's powder is not covered and it is ruined. The company's, though, is. And two-thirds of the Nawat's army, commanded by Mir Jafar, stand still and do nothing at all for the entire engagement.
SPEAKER_01: Clive loses about 20 men. The Nawat flees and is murdered shortly afterwards. Mir Jafar is installed as Nawat, and the company collects what it was promised, which is an enormous sum. And Clive personally collects something in the region of 230,000 pounds, which is a fortune of a scale that is genuinely difficult to convey in today's terms.
SPEAKER_01: Sixteen years later, questioned by a parliamentary committee about exactly this, Clive gave one of the great answers in the history of self-regard. He described walking through vaults thrown open to him, piled with gold and jewels, and then said this by God, Mr. Chairman. At this moment I stand astonished at my own moderation. The Battle of Classy does not conquer India. It takes another century, and it takes books are in 1764, and the grand revenue rights over Bengal in 1765, and a great deal more war after that.
SPEAKER_01: What Classy does is it establishes the principle a commercial corporation, answerable to shareholders in London, has demonstrated that it can decide who governs one of the richest provinces on earth. Everything that follows is that principle being applied at increasing scale, and a hundred years from now, the British state will have to nationalise the company because a private firm running a subcontinent has become too embarrassing to continue. And a note on the timing Bengal produces revenue. Revenue funds the company's armies.
SPEAKER_01: The company's armies take more territory, which produces more revenue. Britain is about to discover it has found a way to make its empire pay for its own expansion. That discovery is going to matter enormously in Episode 3, because it is precisely the thing Britain will fail to do in North America.
William Pitt’s Blueprint For Winning
SPEAKER_01: William Pitt is a politician of no great family, with no fortune of his own, who has spent 20 years in the commons, making himself impossible to ignore and impossible to work with. He is a spectacular orator in an age of spectacular orders. He suffers from gout so badly that he is sometimes carried into the chamber, and from episodes of depression severe enough to remove him from public life for months at a stretch. He is vain to a degree that his contemporaries found remarkable even by the standards of 18th century politics.
SPEAKER_01: When the Duke of Devonshire was trying to form a government, Pitt is supposed to have said to him, My Lord, I am sure I can save this country, and nobody else can. The infuriating thing about Pitt is that he was generally right. He comes into effective control of war policy in the summer of 1757, in coalition with the Duke of Newcastle, who manages Parliament while Pitt runs the war. And he does four things that, between them, win it. First, he stops trying to fight France and Europe. Instead, he pays Frederick to do it.
SPEAKER_01: British money, on a scale never previously committed, keeps a Prussian army in the field tying down the entire French army on the continent. Pitt's own summary of this, which he used more than once, was six words long. America was conquered in Germany. Second, he uses the Royal Navy as the primary strategic instrument rather than as support for land campaigns. Blockade the French coast. Keep the French fleet in harbor, and French colonies cannot be reinforced. A French garrison 6,000 miles away that cannot be resupplied as a garrison that will eventually surrender to whoever shows up.
SPEAKER_01: Third, he attacks French colonies everywhere, at once, with the specific intent of taking assets that can be traded at the peace table. And finally, fourth, at least glamorously, he promotes honability. He puts Jeffrey Amherst, a difficult, sickly, 31-year-old brigadier named James Wolfe into major commands over more senior men, and he takes the political risk of doing it.
SPEAKER_01: Louisburg, the fortress guarding the mouth of the St. Lawrence River in Quebec, falls in July after a siege in which Wolfe distinguishes himself. In November, a British and provincial force under John Ford cuts a new road west and finds Fort Duquesne abandoned and burning. The French having blown it up and left.
SPEAKER_01: Washington is on that expedition. He's twenty-six now. He spends four years arguing that the way to the Ohio ran through Virginia, and Forbes cuts the road through Pennsylvania instead. And they dislike each other intensely about it. He runs into the ruin of the fort that has defined his entire adult life to date and finds a burnt-out shell rebuilding the site and named it after the men running the war. That is why that city that sits at the forks of the Ohio today is called Pittsburgh. Then comes 1759, and the British have to invent a phrase for it, because nothing like it has happened before.
SPEAKER_01: They call it Annas Mirabilis, the Year of the Wonders.
SPEAKER_01: In August, a British and Hanovarian army beats the French at Minden in a battle that includes the famous incident of British infantry advancing on unbroken cavalry and driving it off, which is not supposed to be possible. In the same month, a British fleet destroys a French squadron off of Lagos. In September, Quebec. In November, in a gale off of the Breton coast, Admiral Hawke takes his fleet into uncharted rocky waters at Chivaron Bay and destroys the French Atlantic Fleet, which ends any prospect of French invasion of Britain for the rest of the war.
SPEAKER_01: In the Caribbean, Guadeloupe falls. Walpo's line about it is the one everybody quotes and it earns his place. Our bells are warned threat there, ringing for victories. I do want to flag something about Guadeloupe, because it will matter enormously for episode 3. When Britain takes Guadeloupe in 1759, a serious body of opinion in London considers it a more valuable prize than the whole of Canada. That may sound absurd to you now, it was not absurd then. The reason was sugar. Sugar Islands generated a staggering revenue, and if you were with us for the Haiti series, you'll remember exactly how the arithmetic worked and what it was extracted from.
SPEAKER_01: A single Caribbean island could out-earn a continent of forests. Britain is about to be forced to choose between them. We'll get there.
SPEAKER_01: We are at the St. Lawrence River above Quebec on the night of the 20th of September 1759.
SPEAKER_01: Let me take you inside one of the boats on that river.
SPEAKER_01: There are about 4,500 men going upriver tonight in small crafts on an abtide in the dark past French shore batteries to land at the foot of a cliff that the French have not bothered to fortify it because it is a cliff. In the leading boat is a commanding general. He's 32 years old, he is tubercular and possibly suffering from kidney disease. He has been vomiting and in pain for weeks now, and his own brigadiers have spent the summer in something close to open revolt against his judgment. He is tall, thin, red-haired, with a receding chin, and he does not look remotely like a soldier.
SPEAKER_01: There's a story from an officer who was on that boat that as they drifted down he recited a poem. It was Thomas Gray's elegy, written in a country churchyard, published eight years earlier, and the line he is supposed to have dwelt on was this one.
SPEAKER_01: The officer reported that Wolf then said he would rather have written that poem than take Quebec in the morning.
1759 And The Year Of Wonders
SPEAKER_00: James Wolfe had been besieging Quebec since June and getting nowhere.
SPEAKER_01: The city sits on a bluff above a river, and the Marquis de Montcamp, commanding the French, had declined every invitation to come out and fight, which was a correct decision, and Wolf knew it. Wolf attacked the French position at Beauport, and at the end of July was beaten off with heavy losses. Winter was coming, and when the river froze, the fleet would have to leave, and the campaign would have failed. So through August, he sent detachments down both shores of the St. Lawrence and systematically burned the farms of the Canadian countryside.
SPEAKER_01: Something on the order of fourteen hundred farmsteads were destroyed, along with the harvest in the weeks before winter. The intent was partly to draw Montcalm out and partly to break the colony's capacity to feed itself. It was a deliberate campaign against a civilian population, and it is a considerable part of why the memory of this conquest sits differently in Quebec than it does in London. Wolfe also had opinions about the American provincial troops under his command, which he committed to paper in a letter, at which I'll give you as he wrote it.
SPEAKER_01: The Americans are in general the dirtiest, most contemptible, cowardly dogs that you can conceive. By the 13th of September of 1759, the British get up the cliff. A French sentry challenges the lead boat, and a Highline officer who speaks French answers him convincingly enough. Which is one of those details that sounds invented, but it's not. By dawn, there are 4,500 British soldiers drawn up in line two ranks deep on the farmland west of the city walls. Montcalm, when he's told has a decision to make and roughly no time to make it.
SPEAKER_01: He has troops scattered, some of them hours away, and reinforcements under Bougainville upriver. The textbook answer is to wait, concentrate and attack the afternoon with everything he has. Instead, he attacks almost immediately with what he has, about the same number of men, and makes a French regular and Canadian militia. The two lines come together in mid-morning.
SPEAKER_01: The battle will take only about 15 minutes. The French advance breaks up as it moves, partly because the Canadian militia are trained to fight in a way that does not suit close order lines, and they arrive at the British position ragged and firing early. The British line holds its fire to a distance that later accounts put at somewhere around 40 yards, which requires a degree of discipline that is hard to convey. And then delivers a volley that contemporaries described as sounding like a single shot.
SPEAKER_01: At this point, the French line breaks. Wolf is hit three times, less in the chest, and is carried to the rear. An officer beside him said the French were running. Wolf gave an order about cutting off the retreat to the bridge, and then, by the account of the men holding him, Now, God be praise, I will die in peace. Wolf was 32. Munkalm is hit on the lower body during the retreat, stays on his horse to get inside the walls, and is told that night that he will not live until morning. He asked how long he had, he was told a few hours at most.
SPEAKER_01: So much the better. I shall not leave to see the surrender of Quebec. Montcalm dies the following morning. He was forty-seven. There was no coffin available, and he was buried in a shell crater made by British artillery inside the chapel of the Ursulin Convent. Quebec surrenders five days later.
SPEAKER_01: In four years, Britain has gone from executing an admiral out of blind institutional panic to holding a position no European power has ever really held. It has taken Quebec, Louis Burg, the Ohio Fort, Guadalupe, Senegal, and the naval initiative in every ocean that matters. Its ally has beaten France and Austria on the same continent in five weeks.
SPEAKER_01: Has made itself the effective government of Bengal. The French Atlantic fleet is a wreckage in the rocks of Quiberon Bay.
SPEAKER_01: Every single one of those winds they experienced was bought. The subsidies to Frederick were enormous. They were paid for in cash year after year. The navy that blocated France and took Quiberon Bay had to be built, accrued, ritualed, and repaired. The armies in North America were the largest force Britain had ever sent across the ocean, and every biscuit and every musket ball came by ship.
Wolfe Takes Quebec At A Cost
SPEAKER_01: Britain fought this war the way a man fights a lawsuit he cannot afford to lose, which is to say, by borrowing. By the time it ends, the British national debt will have roughly doubled. The annual interest payment alone will consume a large fraction of government revenue. And Britain will be holding a new empire in North America that is enormous, sparsely settled, expensive to garrison, and full of people, both native and colonial, who have their own strong opinions about what was just decided on their behalf.
SPEAKER_01: In Bengal, Britain acquired territory that generated revenue. The empire there paid for itself and then paid for its own expansion, which is why it kept expanding. In North America, Britain acquired territory that consumed revenue, forests, forts, garrisons, and a frontier that would need policing. The thirteen colonies were prosperous, they were taxed very lightly by British standards, and to a treasury looking for a double debt in 1763, they looked less like subjects who had just fought alongside the king's troops, more like an asset that was underperforming.
SPEAKER_01: Somebody in London is going to look at the ledger and reach an entirely reasonable conclusion. And the people it gets applied to have spent this war being called cowardly dogs by British generals, watching royal captains refuse orders from colonial colonels, and noticing, quietly, that the red coats, who were so formidable in the abstract, could be taken apart on a forest road by an enemy who would not stand still. Britain won the Seven Years' War more completely than any European power had ever won anything.
SPEAKER_01: It is about to find out what that cost.
SPEAKER_01: Next time, on Double Helix, Frederick of Prussia, with his capital occupied and his army destroyed, is safe from annihilation by a single death in St. Petersburg that changes nothing about military situation and everything about the war. In Paris, the diplomats argue seriously about whether a Caribbean island is worth more than the entire landmass of Canada. In the Ohio country, the nations who were promised protection discover what British victory actually means for them. And a Pontiac leads a rising that forces London to draw a line down the map.
SPEAKER_01: And in Westminster, a Chancellor of the Exchequer with a double national debt and a perfectly defensible argument reaches for a solution so obvious, so modest, and so catastrophic that it ends the empire it was designed to save. Until then, thank you for listening. We will see you still.
Podbean