The 7 Years War: The Bill Comes Due (Part 3)
- Published
- Duration
- 45:21
On a summer night in August 1765, a crowd came up Garden Court Street in Boston and spent the next several hours taking the finest house in the north end apart with axes. They stripped the roof. They pulled down the interior walls. They cut down the fruit trees in the garden. And they threw thirty years of irreplaceable manuscript into the street, where the neighbours were out picking the pages from the gutters the following morning.
The man whose house it was had privately advised London that the Stamp Act was a mistake and would never work. It made no difference. He was the most visible officer of the Crown they could reach, and the Crown had just sent a bill.
Part three of three, and the end of the series. Britain has won the Seven Years' War more completely than any European power had ever won anything, and this is the episode where the invoice arrives. A Prussian king nine weeks from the end of everything is rescued by a stroke in St. Petersburg. A room full of Londoners argues, in deadly earnest, over whether one Caribbean sugar island is worth more than the whole of Canada. The French negotiator signs away a continent and walks out of the room satisfied, because he has worked out something nobody across the table has. And on the Ohio frontier, the nations who had balanced two empires against each other for seventy years discover what British victory actually means for them.
Then it comes down to a desk in Whitehall, and a careful, decent, universally respected administrator who adds up a column of figures, gets every single number right, and brings down an empire.
This is also where we make the argument the whole series was built toward: that this war was a fuse, and that it did not burn in a straight line. Over the following century it surfaced in Philadelphia, at Versailles, in Saint-Domingue, and then in places nobody in that peace room could have found on a map, carried by people who were never invited into it.
Got a topic you want covered, or thoughts on the show? Email us at [email protected] — we read everything. And if you're enjoying Double Helix, a rating or review genuinely helps new listeners find us.
More episodes at historyhelix.podview.com
Have feedback? Send us a Text and Interact with us!
Website: https://historyhelix.podview.com/
Twitter: @HistoryHelix
BlueSky: @historyhelix.bsky.social
Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Doublehelixhistory
Instagram: History_Helix
Email: [email protected]
The Night Boston Turns Violent
SPEAKER_01: The finest house in the north end of Boston stands on Garden Court Street. It is three stories of brick, built by a merchant family 60 years ago, with a coppola on the roof that you can see all the way from the harbor. And inside it, there is a library of papers that the owner has been 30 years assembling. Because besides being lieutenant governor of Massachusetts, Chief Justice, and a man of considerable property, he's also a historian. He's writing the history of the colony. How much of the materials he is working from exists nowhere else in the world.
SPEAKER_01: It is the 26th of August, 1765, and he is at supper with his family. Someone comes to the door and tells him there is a crowd on its way.
SPEAKER_01: His eldest daughter refuses to leave without it, which is the only reason he goes at home. They get out through the back.
SPEAKER_01: What happens over the next several hours is not arrived in the sense of something that flares up and burns itself out. It is rather methodical.
SPEAKER_01: They go through the house room by room with axes and break every piece of furniture in it. They drink the wine cellar's dry. They strip the slate off of the roof, and they work at the cuppola until it comes down. They pull down the interior walls, and then they start on the garden. And by dawn, the fruit trees are also down. The papers, they go into the street.
SPEAKER_01: In the morning, the neighbors are picking manuscript pages out of the mud. Some of them are saved, but a great many of them are not. Thirty years of work. Only the copies exist, everything else in the gutters.
SPEAKER_01: The next morning, the Chief Justice of Massachusetts appears in court. Because the court is sitting and he's required to be there. He has no robes, he's wearing clothes that someone lent him, and he tells the room that he does not have a shirt to his name beyond the one he has on. And then he addresses the court, and the record of what he said survives.
SPEAKER_01: Sensible that I am innocent, that all the charges against me are false, I cannot help feeling. And though I am not obliged to give an answer to all the questions that may be put to me by every lawless person, yet I recall God to witness, and I would not for a thousand worlds call my maker to witness to a falsehood. I say, I call my maker to witness that I never, in New England or old, in Great Britain or America, neither directly nor indirectly, was aiding, assisting, or supporting, or in the least promoting or encouraging what is commonly called the Stamp Act.
SPEAKER_01: But on the contrary, I did all in my power and strove as much as in me lay to prevent it.
SPEAKER_01: Listen to what he stops to do in the middle of that event. I would not for a thousand worlds call my maker to witness to a falsehood. This is a careful, lawyerly man standing in barraclothes in front of a courtroom, and he interrupts his own oath to make absolutely sure that the oath is properly framed. He was telling the truth. Thomas Hutchinson had privately advised London that the Stamp Act was a mistake and that it would not work. It made no difference at all. He was the most visible officer of the Crown in Massachusetts.
SPEAKER_01: The Crown had just sent the bill.
A Show About National DNA
SPEAKER_01: You know how they say you can't understand someone until you walk a mile in their shoes? Well, I'd argue you can't understand a nation until you've walked through its history. Not just to highlight Rio or the sanitized version you find in textbooks. I mean really getting into its DNA. Those defining moments that shaped everything that came after. Those moments where paths were chosen, where decisions were made in palaces and backrooms and city streets that changed the course of millions of lives.
SPEAKER_01: I'm your host, Paul, and this is Double Helix, Blueprint of Nations, where we unravel the genetic code of countries through their most transformative moments. Think of it like ancestry testing, but for entire nations. We dig deep into the historical DNA, finding those crucial moments that made countries who they are today.
SPEAKER_01: Canada, the Ohio, Florida, Senegal, a string of Caribbean islands, Bengal, and command of every ocean that mattered. The church bells of London had been worn out with ringing. Twelve years and eight hundred miles separate those bells from that house on Garden Court Street. And the line that runs between them is almost perfectly straight. That line is what this episode is about. Here's what I want you holding on to. Because it is the whole reason this series exists. Everything that happens from here happens because of a number.
SPEAKER_01: Britain borrowed to win this war on a scale that no state had ever really attempted before. And the moment the shooting stopped, somebody had to work out who was going to pay for it. That question is asked in London and in Paris, and in Berlin, and on the river in the Ohio country. And every single person he gets asked of gives the same answer. Not me.
SPEAKER_01: There are three places we need to be today. The first is a peace table, where the war formally ends, and where one man signs away a continent and walks out of the room perfectly satisfied with his afternoon. The second is the four is where this whole series began, where the people who actually live on the ground find out what British victory means for them. And the third is a desk in Whitehall, where a diligent, decent, universally respected administrator sets up a column of figures, gets every single number right, and brings down an empire.
SPEAKER_01: And then there is the part that matters most of all, which is what a fuse actually does once you have lit it. Because this war does not end in 1763, it goes underground, and it comes up somewhere else, and it keeps coming up for the next hundred years, in places that nobody standing in the peace room could have found on a map at the time.
Victory Brings A Massive Bill
SPEAKER_01: For now, let's start at the table.
SPEAKER_01: And in the winter of 1761, it very nearly stops in the worst possible way for one of the combatants. Let me put you in a room in Berlin with a man who is Finnish, and who knows he is Finnish.
SPEAKER_01: Frederick of Prussia has been at war for five years. The previous October, a combined Russian and Austrian force walked into Berlin, his own capital city, and occupied it for four days. There was nothing whatsoever that he could do about it. At Kunersdorf in 1759, he lost most of his army in a single afternoon. At Torgau in 1760, he won a battle, but it cost him so many men that it was barely distinguishable from losing one. The army he has left is not the army of 1757 anymore. The professionals are all dead.
SPEAKER_01: He's filling his regiments with prisoners of war, deserters, and conscripts out of occupied territory, and he knows exactly what they are worth. He has lost Silicia again, which was the entire point of the war in the first place, and he's down to somewhere around 60,000 men against three empires. And then, that winter, Britain stops paying him. Pitt had resigned in October. The new government under Lord Butte wanted out of a continental war it had never liked. And over the following months, the subsidy that had kept Prussia in the field was quietly allowed to lapse.
SPEAKER_01: By now, Frederick is 49 years old, and his own officers describe him as looking 20 years older than that. We talked in our last episode about what he had decided to do rather than watch his kingdom destroyed. He was suicidal, and nothing about that decision has changed, except that it has got a good deal closer now. What has changed now is that he's alone. For five years, the one fixed point in his entire position was that Britain was in it with him. That is gone now, and it went without a battle.
SPEAKER_01: He went out in a cabinet room in London for a single line in a budget.
SPEAKER_01: And then, in St. Petersburg, Russia, on the 5th of January 1762, a 52-year-old woman dies of the stroke.
SPEAKER_01: She had put the full weight of the Russian Empire behind destroying him, and it had very nearly worked. Now, on the ground, her death changes nothing. The Russian armies are exactly where they were before. East Prussia is still occupied, and the spring campaign that finishes Prussia off for good is still perfectly possible. What her death changes, though, is whose signature goes on the orders. Because her heir is her nephew, and her nephew is a German-born prince who has idolized Frederick the Great since boyhood with an intensity that everyone around him found embarrassing.
SPEAKER_01: He collected miniature portraits of the men. He got a Prussian uniform. There are accounts of him referring to Frederick as his master.
SPEAKER_01: Peter III takes the throne in January. In February, he suspends operations. In May, he signs a treaty handing back every single inch of Russian conquest unconditionally and asking for nothing in return at all. And then he goes further than that and puts a corps of Russian troops under Frederick's personal command to go and fight the Austrians who had been his own allies eight weeks earlier. Frederick, when the news reaches him, is said to have answered in Italian. It was six words, an old probearer, not a gracious one.
SPEAKER_01: Morta la bestia, morto il banano. That is the beast that the poison.
SPEAKER_01: In July, Peter is deposed by his own wife, who becomes Catherine the Great, and who thinks the whole business is madness. But she does not restart the war, and so Russia is out, and with Russia out, the coalition collapses.
SPEAKER_01: In February of 1763, in a Saxon hunting lodge called Huber Sterberg, Prussia and Austria sign a peace. And it is one of the strangest documents in European history because it changes nothing whatsoever about things on the ground. Everybody goes back to the borders of 1756. Frederick keeps Silicia, which he already had. Maria Teresa gets nothing, which is what she had. So six years, three great powers, and the map at the end of it is the map from the beginning of it.
SPEAKER_01: Here's the first entry in the ledger, then because somebody did pay for all this. Somewhere around four hundred thousand Prussians are dead, soldiers and civilians together. Out of a population of four and a half million. That is one person in every eleven whole districts of the kingdom were left depopulated. And Frederick spends the rest of his reign draining marshes and importing settlers and running a state whose finances never fully recovered. And yet, he comes out of this as Frederick the Great, the most admired soldier in Europe, the man who held off the world.
SPEAKER_01: There is one thing to carry forward here, because it picks up a thread from our last episode. What gets written down afterwards, and what gets taught in the military academies of Prussia and Germany and elsewhere, and what is believed for a century and a half is that Prussia came through this on discipline and nerve alone. However, there is another version, one that is a good deal less glamorous and a good deal more honest. In that version, a fifty-two-year-old woman had a stroke at exactly the right moment and was replaced by a man who collected miniature portraits of the enemy.
SPEAKER_01: In other words, courage made it into the story that I got told.
SPEAKER_01: And through the same stretch of months, while Frederick is being rescued by an obituary, London is having an argument with itself about what it actually wants to keep after the war.
Canada Or The Sugar Islands
SPEAKER_01: Now, this sounds administrative. It is in fact one of the most consequential arguments of the entire century. It was conducted substantially in cheap pamphlets and sold on the streets. And the question at the heart of it was very simple. Britain has taken Canada. It has also taken Guadeloupe and Martinique and Havana and Manila. It cannot possibly keep all of that. France will not sign a peace that strips it completely bare. And Britain has no real appetite for governing the whole lot anyway. So something has to go back.
SPEAKER_01: So which is it? Do you keep Canada or do you keep the sugar islands? I need you to understand that in 1762, this is not an obvious question, and the people arguing for the sugar were not fools. Although Guadeloupe is just one island, in a good year, that one island produced sugar worth more than the entire exports of all 13 American colonies combined. Canada, by comparison, produced furs, a great deal of snow, and 60,000 French Catholic subjects who would need governing and who would cost money.
SPEAKER_01: One of those two things made the treasury money, the other one was going to cost money. And every pamphlet in this argument talks about Guadeloupe as a yield. They talk about a hogshead per acre, and duties per hogshead, and tonnage landed at Bristol. Nobody on either side of the argument spends much ink at all on the fact that the yield is produced by human beings who are worked to death on a schedule and then replaced by ship. The arithmetic was impeccable. The arithmetic was also the only thing anybody thought was worth doing.
SPEAKER_01: Benjamin Franklin, who is in London at the time, writes a pamphlet arguing for Canada. His case is partly strategic. He argues that an expanding British America needs the continent, and that it will be forever vulnerable with France sitting on its flank. And his case is partly arithmetic on its own. He points out that the colonies are growing so fast that within a century the center of gravity of the whole British Empire will have moved to the western side of the Atlantic. The best argument on the other side, though, came out anonymously, as this things usually did.
SPEAKER_01: It is generally attributed to a man William Burke, a kinsman of the more famous Edmund. Although a minority of scholars put it down to Charles Townsend, and one authority thinks Edmund had a hand in it himself. The point is, someone wrote it. And whoever it was understood what was coming better than anyone in the British government did. The argument runs like this. Remove Canada, and you remove the check on the colonies. It will spread west without limit. And what you will be left with is a numerous, hardy, independent people holding a strong country with less and less reasons to talk to London at all.
SPEAKER_01: Grasp too much territory, pamphlet warns, and you will may well lose what you already have. And lose it a lot sooner than you think. And then comes a sentence that everyone remembers.
SPEAKER_01: That is 16 years before the Declaration of Independence, and it was written by a man who had never once set foot in America. Yet, he had described the United States, and he had identified the mechanism that produced it, which is simply the removal of fear. At the end, Britain keeps Canada, Guadeloupe and Martinique go back to France.
SPEAKER_01: The Treaty of Paris is signed on the 10th of February 1763, and on paper it is a triumph without precedent in British history. France surrenders Canada and everything east of the Mississippi. It surrenders Senegal. It abandons its political ambitions in India entirely, and keeps a handful of trading posts with no right to fortify any of them. Spain, which joined the war late and badly, hands over Florida in order to get Havana back. And France compensates Spain by quietly handing it Louisiana, which means that France has now left North America altogether.
SPEAKER_01: In return, Britain gives back Guadeloupe, Martinique, Havana, Manila, and Goray. And on the French side of the table, the Duke de Chosul signs it and does not behave remotely like a man who has just lost.
SPEAKER_01: He is intelligent and extremely cynical, and his own reading of what he has just done is on the record. He thought the sugar was worth more than Canada, which is a defensible position. And he thought something else as well, which turned out to be exactly right. He thought that with France gone from North America, the British colonies will no longer have any need of Britain. He expected them to separate, and he expected it to happen within a generation. So he starts preparing for that day immediately by rebuilding the French Navy, which he did with great energy and considerable success over the following decade.
SPEAKER_01: The British negotiators have taken a continent, and they are going home to work out how to pay for it. The French negotiators have taken the sugar, kept the fishing rights, and walked out of the room believing that he has set a trap that springs in about fifteen years. He was only off by two. But before Chasul's trap can spring, that bill has to land somewhere else. And it does not land first on anyone who was in that room. It lands on the people who were never invited into the room. On the ground, this whole thing started over.
SPEAKER_01: Now, everything you have just heard, Frederick's reprieve, the pamphlet war, Chosul's signing with a straight face, all of that is happening in the same three years, is what I'm about to tell you. It is the same calendar, but it is a completely different world. And while London and Paris are busy deciding who owns the Ohio country, this is what is actually happening.
Pontiac’s War And Frontier Panic
SPEAKER_01: On the Ohio Country. So let's go back to where this series began. For 70 years, the nations of the Ohio Country and the Great Lakes have been playing two empires off against each other, and it has worked. Both sides needed them, both sides courted them. The French in particular had built an entire diplomatic system of gift giving, which Europeans sometimes mistook for primary, which was nothing of the sort. It was how alliance was expressed and renewed. It meant powder and shot, blankets, tools, and food in the bad winter.
SPEAKER_01: It meant the annual council, the exchange of presents, and the language of fathers and children. Then, in 1760, the French leave, and the system they were one half of leaves with them. And by 1761, the British commander in North America is looking at all that gift giving and seeing a line item on a page. Jeffrey Amherst is a competent soldier and, on this particular subject, something very close to a bigot. He regards the Native nations as the defeated parties in a war they lost. He regards the gifts as tribute, and he considers it absurd to go paying people who are no longer needed.
SPEAKER_01: So he decides to stop. He restricts the sale of powder and lead, which, for people who now hunt with firearms, is not a diplomatic snug, but a direct threat to their food supply. He lets traders set their prices wherever they like, and he lets settlers across the mountains. As this is happening, a man called Naolin, the Law prophet, who has a vision and begins preaching it through the Ohio towns, takes rice. His message is that the people have been corrupted by their dependence on European goods, European alcohol, European waste, that the master of life is displeased with them, and that the remedy is to put all of it down and drive the British out.
SPEAKER_01: This is a religious revival, and it travels a great deal faster than any political message could.
SPEAKER_01: And it goes off everywhere at once. It gets called Pontiac's War after the Ottawa war leader who besieges Detroit, and that name undersells it badly because this was not one man's rising. Shawnee, Delaware, Seneca, Ottawa, Lejigwe, Pottawanomie, Wyandotte, Miami, and all others are on the move in a coordinated season of attacks across a thousand miles of frontier. Of the 12 British forts west of the Appalachians, eight of them fall inside a few weeks. Detroit and Fort Pitt hold out under siege. Some 2,000 settlers are killed or carried off, and British forces retaliate in kind.
SPEAKER_01: At Fort Pitt in June, something happens that I need to tell you about. One of the men inside of the fort is a militia captain and traitor named William Trent. Hold on to William Trent, because you have met him before. Trent is the Pennsylvania traitor who was sent out to build a fort at the forks of the Ohio in the spring of 1754, and whose men were standing there when the French came down the river and took it from them. He has been in this story since the first ten minutes of episode one. Let me take you to the parley outside of the walls of this fort on the 24th of June of 1763.
SPEAKER_01: Two Delaware emissaries have come to ask the garrison to abandon the fort and withdraw, which is a reasonable thing to ask, and which is in fact how these things usually are settled. The commander refuses. The emissaries then ask for provisions for the journey back, which is ordinary courtesy. Inside the fort, there is a smallpox outbreak. Trent keeps a journal, and here's what he recorded in it, in his own hand. I want you to listen to the first six words. Out of our regard for them, we gave them two blankets and a handkerchief out of the smallpox hospital.
SPEAKER_01: I hope you will have the desired effect.
SPEAKER_01: Out of our regard for them. That is the language of hospitality.
SPEAKER_01: And in the sentence immediately after it, it tells you precisely what the gift was for. And then, separately, about two weeks later, and apparently knowing nothing at all about what Trent had already done, General Armherst writes to Colonel Henry Bouquet three letters that pass between those two men, and the horror of them is how ordinary they sound. Amherst goes first, as a postscript, phrased as a question. Could it not be contrived to send the smallpox among those disaffected tribes of Indians?
SPEAKER_01: We must on this occasion use every stratagem in our power to reduce them. Puke replies.
SPEAKER_01: I should be very glad your scheme for hunting them down by dogs could take effect.
SPEAKER_01: Notice what passes between these two men without a flicker. There is a question, and there is a proposal to add dog hunting to it, and there is an approval of both, no argument, no hesitation, and no sense on either side that the other man might find any of it objectionable. The commander-in-chief of British forces in North America proposed biological warfare against the civilian population in writing to a subordinate, and used the word extirpate. What historians genuinely do argue about is whether it actually worked, because smallpox was already moving through the Ohio country from other sources, and you cannot cleanly trace a specific epidemic back to a specific blanket.
SPEAKER_01: That is a real scholarly debate, and it is a debate about causation. It is not a debate about intent. Intent is written down. Eventually, Amherst is recalled to London later that year. Not for this, though. He's recalled for losing control of the frontier.
The Proclamation Line Betrayal
SPEAKER_01: London, looking at a frontier war it cannot afford, reaches for the cheapest thing available, which is a line on a map. On the 7th of October, 1763, the Royal Proclamation draws a boundary straight down the crest of the Appalachians. Everything west of that line is reserved for the native nations. Colonial settlement beyond it is prohibited. Private land purchase beyond it is prohibited, and existing claims are null and void. Read generously, it is the first formal British acknowledgement that native nations hold their land by rights rather than by suffrage.
SPEAKER_01: And it becomes a foundational document in Canadian law for exactly that reason. Read practically, it is a government that has just doubled its national debt, trying very hard to avoid paying for another Indian war. And in the Thirteen Colonies, it lands as a straightforward betrayal. Because the entire reason Virginia went into the Ohio country back in 1754 was to take that land. Men had died for it, companies had been chartered for it, and now London, having been handed the whole thing by colonial blood as well as British, has declared it close.
SPEAKER_01: Here now is the second entry in the legend. The Ohio Nations were the only people in this entire story who were fighting for ground they actually lived on. They come out of it with the leverage completely gone. Because the two empire games that had kept them independent for 70 years ended the moment one of those empires left. What they are given instead is a line that London will not enforce and that the colonies will not respect. And we know for a fact it will not be respected. Because one of the men who fully intends to ignore it writes it down.
SPEAKER_01: George Washington, who was quietly accumulating Western lands all through the late 1760s, wrote to his surveyor William Crawford about the proclamation of 1767. There is a parenthesis in the first line of it that tells you he knew exactly how the letter would read.
SPEAKER_01: But this I say between ourselves, than as a temporary expedient to quiet the minds of the Indians. A must fall, of course, in a few years, especially when those Indians consent to our occupying those lands. Any person, therefore, who neglects the present opportunity of hunting out good lands, and in some measure making and distinguishing them for his own, in order to keep others from settling them, will never regain it.
SPEAKER_01: That is the whole plan in one paragraph. Written by the future first president of the United States.
SPEAKER_01: Now comes the big one.
Grenville Builds Policy From Numbers
SPEAKER_01: And he gets settled on a desk.
SPEAKER_01: Let me take you to Whitehall and show you the numbers because everything that follows is on one page. None of it is irrational.
SPEAKER_01: George Granville becomes first lord of the treasury in April of 1763. He is careful, humorless, and extremely diligent with a reputation as possibly the dullest man in Parliament. And he has inherited the following situation. The national debt before the war was somewhere around 73 million pounds. It is now about 133 million. It has roughly doubled in seven years. The annual interest alone runs to over four and a half million pounds against a total government revenue of about eight million. So more than half of everything the state takes in is going straight out again to service borrowing.
SPEAKER_01: At home, the land tax has been sitting at wartime levels for years, and the country gentlemen in parliament, who are precisely the men Grenville needs on his side, want it brought down. Cider has just been taxed, and there has been riots about it.
SPEAKER_01: And then there is all this new territory. Around 10,000 men are now being kept under arms in North America permanently. In peacetime. Because the proclamation line has to be policed, and Pontiac's Rising has just demonstrated exactly what happens to a frontier that isn't police. The force costs something in the region of a quarter of a million pounds per year.
SPEAKER_01: Now look at all of this from his side of the desk. The colonies are prosperous, the war was fought substantially in their defense, the French threat on their border has been removed at enormous expense to the British taxpayer. And the average colonist pays, by most contemporary estimates, somewhere between a twentieth and a fiftieth of the tax burden carried by the average person back in Britain. So if you are Grenville, you're not sitting there planning an outrage. You're looking at a bill and at a group of beneficiaries who have barely contributed to it, and you are proposing that they cover a fraction of the cost of their own garrison.
SPEAKER_01: That is a defensible position. And he held it sincerely, and he put it to the commons plainly. Protection and obedience are reciprocal. Great Britain protects America. America is bound to yield obedience. If not, tell me when the Americans were emancipated. When they want the protection of this kingdom, they are always very ready to ask for it. Protection has always been afforded them in the most full and ample manner. The nation has run itself into an immense debt to give them this protection. And now they are called upon to contribute a small share towards the public expense, an expense arising from themselves.
SPEAKER_01: They renounce your authority, insult your officers, and break out, I might almost say, into open rebellion.
SPEAKER_01: Every sentence of that is true. The debt was real, the protection was real, the share being requested genuinely was small, and the officers genuinely were being insulted. A sensible, diligent man built an entire policy on it. However, the questions he never asked, the one he does not appear to recognize as a question at all, is whether Parliament has the right to tax people who sent no one to sit in it. The colonists were not arguing about the size of the bill necessarily.
SPEAKER_01: As a result, here's what comes off of his desk the Sugar Act in 1764, which actually lowers the duty on molasses, but which intends, for the first time, to genuinely collect it. Then the Currency Act, restricting colonial paper money, and the Quartering Act. And then, in March of 1765, the Stamp Act, which requires a revenue stamp on newspapers, on legal documents, on licenses, on contracts, on almanacs, and on playing cards, effective the first of November, seventeen sixty-five.
Why The Stamp Act Detonates
SPEAKER_01: It is projected to raise about sixty thousand pounds a year, which is not quite a third of the cost of the garrison. Yet it detonates.
SPEAKER_01: Every attorney pays for it on every document. Every newspaper pays for it on every issue. Grenville has managed to tax the people who write the pamphlets and the people who print them. Second, it is an internal tax. Customs duties on trade had been accepted for a century as a legitimate regulation of commerce. But a stamp on a will drawn up in Connecticut is a direct tax on British subjects by a parliament in which they are subject but has no members in at all. And the colonists had a long and serious constitutional tradition to draw on in saying so.
SPEAKER_01: And third, violations are to be tried in Vice Admiralty courts, which sit without juries. To a people who regard trial by jury as an inheritance rather than a privilege, that is an insult underneath the injury. Nine colonies send delegates to a Congress in New York in October of 1765. Merchants organize non-importation agreements, and those agreements hit British exporters hard enough that the exporters themselves start loving Harland. The Sons of Liberty organize in the streets, and stamp distributors up and down the coast are persuaded to resign, a number of them under threat of what had happened in Boston back in August.
SPEAKER_01: Boston in August is where we started. That was not a mop picking a target at random. That was the bill arriving in person, at the best address it could reach. By the 1st of November of 1765, the day the act is supposed to take effect, there's almost nobody left anywhere in North America willing to sell a stamp.
SPEAKER_01: Parliament repeals it in March of 1766, under commercial pressure, and a new government takes credit for it. And William Pitt, who is back in the Commons and still the most electrifying speaker of the time, tells the House something that got him cheered in Boston, but never entirely forgiven at home. It is my opinion that this kingdom has no right to lay a tax upon the colonies. I rejoice that America has resisted. Three millions of people so dead to all the feelings of liberty as voluntarily to submit to be slaves would have been fit instruments to make slaves of the rest.
SPEAKER_01: But it is the part that frightened people. He's not saying the Americans are right about this particular text. He's saying that a people who would accept it would be a people fit for slavery, and that a parliament capable of imposing it on them would be a parliament capable of imposing it on anyone else, Englishmen at home included. But on the very same day that it repealed the Stamp Act, the Parliament also passed the Declaratory Act, which asserted the right to bind the colonies in all cases whatsoever.
SPEAKER_01: Which is to say, we are not doing this now, we are not conceding that we cannot do it later.
SPEAKER_01: At the end, both sides walk out of 1766, believing that they have won, and believing that the question is still open. That is the worst available outcome to any crisis, and it guarantees a second larger crisis.
Repeal And The Declaratory Warning
SPEAKER_01: The thing about a fuse is that it does not burn in a straight line. It does not burn anywhere you can see it. In 1766, everyone in London believes this is over. A tax was tried, the tax failed, the tax was withdrawn, the principle, though, was preserved, and the ledger will get balanced some other way next session. There is no sense anywhere in that government that anything has been started. But the math does not go away. And the question underneath the math does not go away either. And over the next hundred years, that unanswered question is going to surface again and again and again in places that look like they have nothing whatsoever to do with a skirmish in a Pennsylvania wood in 1754.
SPEAKER_01: It surfaces in Philadelphia, where thirteen colonies have just been saved by an empire and decide that they would rather not be in one. It surfaces in Versailles, where Chosul's rebuilt navy is sitting and waiting, where the revenge that France has been building towards since the day he signed eventually costs so much that a French king has to summon an assembly that has not met since 1614 to ask for money. And it surfaces in Saint-Domingue, where half a million enslaved people on the richest sugar island on earth are listening very carefully indeed to what Paris has been saying about the rights of men.
SPEAKER_01: We have been to Saint-Domingue on this show. We will be going back. And then it goes somewhere that nobody in that peace room in 1763 was even thinking about. Because here's the funny thing about ideas. Ideas are not like territory. You cannot hand an idea back across a negotiating table. Once this has been said out loud and printed in a language that ordinary people can read, that a government which taxes you without asking you has no claim on your obedience, then that sentence is loose in the world, and it does not stay where it was written.
SPEAKER_01: He gets picked up in Caracas, Buenos Aires, by men who have read the same pamphlets and drawn the obvious conclusions about Spain. He gets picked up in Dublin. He gets picked up eventually in places that will spend the following century turning it into a demand for a country of their own. The map we live on now, with all of its borders, its anthems, and its founding days, is substantially the long result of this one bill going unpaid.
SPEAKER_01: After nine years of war, fought on four continents, in February of 1763, the only people who got what they wanted were the ones who were already in the room.
The Fuse Spreads Across Centuries
SPEAKER_00: The rest of the story belongs to everybody who wasn't in the room.
SPEAKER_01: Next time, Double Helix, Boston, 1770. A crowd, a nervous squad of soldiers, five that in the streets, and the defense lawyer nobody expected to take the case.
SPEAKER_01: John Adams called the whole business 13 clocks somehow made to strike us one, and said it was a wonder it ever happened. Until then, thank you for listening. We will see you soon.
Podbean