The American Revolution: The Rights Of Englishmen (Part 1)
- Published
- Duration
- 1:02:01
On a frozen March night in 1770, British soldiers fired into a crowd on King Street in Boston, and the first man to fall was a sailor named Crispus Attucks, who had once been somebody's property. Within a week, the most principled lawyer in Boston agreed to defend the soldiers. He won by telling the jury who was really to blame, and he pointed at Attucks.
This is the first episode of Thirteen Clocks, our five-part series on the American War of Independence, and it starts where the national story usually ends its first chapter. We follow six years in which a quarrel between British subjects over tea duties and town meetings turns into a war nobody on Lexington Common meant to start. The road runs through John Adams's courtroom, the Boston Tea Party, Lexington and Concord, and the slaughter on Breed's Hill. Along the way, enslaved people in Boston and Virginia read the language of liberty more carefully than the men using it.
Then, in November 1775, seven months before the Declaration of Independence, the royal governor of Virginia offers freedom to any enslaved man belonging to a rebel who will fight for the King. Hundreds reach his ships within weeks, and some of them march under the words "Liberty to Slaves." George Washington calls him the most formidable enemy America has.
This episode is about who the rights of Englishmen were really for, and what the people who were never offered them did when a war gave them a choice.
Got a topic you want covered, or thoughts on the show? Email us at [email protected]. We read everything. And if you're enjoying Double Helix, a rating or review genuinely helps new listeners find us.
More episodes at historyhelix.podview.com.
Have feedback? Send us a Text and Interact with us!
Website: https://historyhelix.podview.com/
Twitter: @HistoryHelix
BlueSky: @historyhelix.bsky.social
Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Doublehelixhistory
Instagram: History_Helix
Email: [email protected]
A Messier Revolution Begins
SPEAKER_00: Hey everyone, this is Paul. Welcome back. If you were with us for World Set of Blaze, which was our series on the Seven Years' War, you know we spent three episodes watching Britain win the biggest war in the eighteenth century. And then we discovered what it cost. Our last episode ended with the bill on the table. This series is ostensibly about the people who refused to pay it. And what happened to everyone standing nearby when they did. Now most of us grew up with this story. At least if you live in the United States.
SPEAKER_00: And someone was coming won't really match the version that you learn in school. That's why I mean that's what this show is for. The real thing is much messier. It involves a lot more people, harder choices, questionable morals. Frankly, it makes for better stories. Across five episodes, we'll go from street fighting in Boston to a hot summer in Philadelphia, somewhere in the middle. you'll find out why the French were so keen to help. You'll also see the Seven Years' War become the gift that keeps on giving.
SPEAKER_00: This through line of unintended consequences. What the CIA would later call blowback, working its way across the world for decades to come. As always, before we start, everything we make, every series plus the reading behind it, lives at historyhelix.com. We're also active on social media. If you've been enjoying the show, those are the best places to find out more and the best way to tell a friend where to find us. Again, please support the show by leaving a rating and a review. Just takes thirty seconds, and it helps a lot.
King Street And The First Shots
SPEAKER_00: It is the fifth of March, seventeen seventy. A little after 9 o'clock on a Monday night. There is no on the ground in Boston. Packed hard and iced for the carts that run. There is one soldier standing in front of the custom house on King Street.
SPEAKER_00: The soldier's name is Hugh White. He's a private in the 29th Regiment of Foot, and he has the misfortune of guarding the building where the King's revenue is kept. In a town where two regiments of the King's soldiers have been living among the people for a year and a half, where nobody wanted them. A wigmaker's apprentice named Edward Garrick, a teenager, walks past and shouts something at an officer passing the other way. The officer, he says, never paid his master's bill. It is an insult about money, the kind a boy throws at a man who cannot be seen to answer it.
SPEAKER_00: Private White answers it. He steps off his post and hits the boy on the side of the head with the butt of his musket.
SPEAKER_00: Garrick's friends come running. Then they're friends. And somewhere across town, a church bell starts to ring. And then another. In Boston, in 1770, the bell rung at night means fire. People come out of their houses with leather buckets. They arrive in King Street and find no fire. Just a lone sentry backed up against the customs house steps. And a crowd of boys and sailors and rope workmen pelting him with snow and lumps of ice, daring him to shoot.
SPEAKER_00: He shouts for the main guard. Captain Thomas Preston, the officer of the day, comes down the street with a corporal and six privates, bayonets fixed. He pushes through the crowd to stand him in a half circle in front of the sentry. Now there are eight muskets. Maybe three or four hundred people in the street. More coming. The people throw snowballs, and ice and oyster shells, and stacks of corporate. And the balders come right up to the bayonet and strike at the barrels of blood. Some of them shout at the soldiers they're not fired.
SPEAKER_00: Others shout at the show.
SPEAKER_00: Among the men at the front is the 12 statements. about 47 years old, 6'2, with a heavy stick in his hand. He has been in Boston between voyages. the wheels. His name is Crispus Addocks. 20 years ago, a farmer in Framingham had been advertised in the Boston paper, offering a reward for a runaway slave called Christmas. six foot two, short curled hair, his knees nearer together than common, and historians are fairly confident it is the same man. Whoever he was in 1750, tonight he's a free man, a sailor, and he's standing on King Street in front of a line of British infantry.
SPEAKER_00: Private Hugh Montgomery is knocked off his feet by a throne club. He gets up.
SPEAKER_00: Whose musket went off first was never proven. Not at the trial that happened after, not since. But most accounts say it was his.
SPEAKER_00: Two balls take Crispus Addicts in the chest. He's dead before anyone can reach him. Samuel Gray, who worked as a roadwalk, is shot through the head. James Caldwell, the mate of a ship, is hit twice. A 17-year-old apprentice named Samuel Maverick is hit by a ball that ricochets, and he dies the next morning. Patrick Carr, an Irishman who made leather breeches, will take nine days to die. Six more people are wounded. Three days later, the town turns out for the funeral. Most of Boston walks behind the coffins.
SPEAKER_00: Attics called will have no homes in the town, so they are laid out beforehand in Fanel Hall as strangers. Then the four of them are buried together in the granary burying grounds. The fifth joins them when he dies.
SPEAKER_00: Nobody walking behind those coffins is talking about independence. They have British subjects. They are angry about soldiers in their town. But in a little over five years, men from the farms and around this town will be firing on the king's soldiers from behind the stone walls of the Conquered Road. A year after that, colonies that could barely agree on anything will declare themselves a nation and go to war with the most powerful empire on earth.
SPEAKER_00: The first men to fall tonight, the one at the front of the crowd, had been somebody's property. When that war comes, a great many people in the position he once held could look at both armies and ask the question his life raises, which is whose liberty this fight is actually about? And a good number of them will find that the better offer comes from the king.
SPEAKER_00: This is part one of the American Revolution. The Rights of Englishmen. You know how they say you can't understand someone until you walk a mile in their shoes? Well, I'd argue you can't understand a nation until you've walked through its history. Not just to highlight Rio or the sanitized version you find in textbooks. I mean really getting into its DNA. Those defining moments that shaped everything that came after. Those moments where paths were chosen, where decisions were made in palaces and backrooms and city streets that changed the course of millions of lives.
SPEAKER_00: I'm your host, Paul, and this is Double Helix, Blueprint of Nations, where we unraveled the genetic code of countries through their most transformative moments. Think of it like ancestry testing, but for entire nations. We dig deep into the historical DNA, finding those crucial moments that made countries who they are today.
SPEAKER_00: Late in his life, John Adams wrote a letter trying to explain to a younger generation how improbable the whole thing had been. There were thirteen colonies, he said, with different constitutions, different churches, different peoples, and different habits, and they barely knew each other and mostly did not like each other. Here's how he put it in 1818. The colonies had grown up under constitutions of governments so different, there was so great a variety of religions, they were composed of so many different nations, their customs, manners, and habits had so little resemblance, and their intercourse had been so rare, their knowledge of each other so imperfect, that to unite them in the same principle in theory and the same system of action was certainly a very difficult enterprise.
SPEAKER_00: The complete accomplishment of it, in so short a time and by such simple means, was perhaps a singular example in the history of mankind. Thirteen clocks were made to strike together, a perfection of mechanism which no artist had ever before effected. That is the through line of this series, and Adams is right. It is a marvel. It is also a marvel with a lot of moving parts that the clockmaker never mentions. And over the next five episodes we're going to open the case. Some of those parts were set moving in the Seven Years' War, and there are three I want to follow in particular.
SPEAKER_00: The first is that this was a civil war fought between neighbors, in which something like a fifth of the colonies stayed loyal to the crown, and tens of thousands were driven into exile at the end of it. The second is that this was one with French money, French powder and a French fleet by a friend that had been planning its revenge since the day it signed away Canada. And the third, which is where this episode lands, is that the largest offer of freedom made to enslaved people during the whole war came from the side we were taught to call the tyrants.
SPEAKER_00: Before we go back to King Street, though, there are four years we need to cross.
How Taxes Put Troops In Boston
SPEAKER_00: And they explain how a quarrel over a stamp ended with soldiers in a Boston street.
SPEAKER_00: When we left the Seven Years' War, it was 1766. Parliament had repelled the Stamp Act. The war debt was still sitting on the treasury's books, and so the next year a new Chancellor of the Exchequer, Charles Townsend, went looking for revenue again. What made his duties dangerous was less what they taxed than what the money was for. It was earmarked to pay the salaries of royal governors and judges in America, which meant that for the first time those men would no longer depend on colonial assemblies for their pay.
SPEAKER_00: If you pay a judge, you have a good deal of say over the judge, and the colonists understood that perfectly well. To collect it all, Towson set up a new Board of Customs Commissioners, and he put his headquarters in Boston. Then, in September of 1767, Towson died suddenly and left his policy behind for other men to enforce. That winter, a Pennsylvania lawyer named John Dickinson published a series of essays called Letters from a Farmer in Pennsylvania, and they were reprinted in nearly every newspaper in the colonies.
SPEAKER_00: Dickinson was a cautious man, and he would later refuse to sign the Declaration of Independence. On this question, however, he was not cautious at all. Here then, my dear countrymen, rouse yourselves and behold the ruin hanging over your heads. If you once admit that Great Britain may lay duties upon her exportations to us for the purpose of levying money on us only, she then will have nothing to do but to lay those duties on the articles which she prohibits us to manufacture, and the tragedy of American liberty is finished.
SPEAKER_00: In February 1768, the Massachusetts House sent a circular letter to other colonial assemblies asking them to make common cause. London had just created a brand new Secretary of State for the colonies, which was one more office the enlarged empire now needed, and the first men to hold it, Lord Hillsborough, ordered Massachusetts to take the letter back. The House voted 92-17 to refuse, and for years afterwards, 92 was a patriot toast. That June, the Customs Commissioners seized John Hancock's sloop, the Liberty, on a smuggling charge, and a crowd ran the customs men off the waterfront.
SPEAKER_00: The commissioners fled to Castle William, the fort on the harbor, and asked London once again for troops. Now, here's where the last war comes back into it. Remember the army Grenville was trying to pay for in our last episode? The one kept in America to police the frontier? On the 1st of October 1768, two regiments of it, the 14th and the 29th, came ashore at Long Wharf from Halifax and marched up into Boston with drums beating and bayonets fixed. In other words, a garrison that existed to hold the Ohio country was now a quarter in a colonial port town among the people it was supposed to be protecting.
SPEAKER_00: What followed was a year and a half of friction. There were sentries on the commons and soldiers drilling in the streets on the Sabbath, of duty soldiers who were badly paid, to casual work around the docks for less than local men would accept, and there were fights over it. In February 1770, a customs informer named Ebenezer Richardson, with a crowd throwing stones at his house, fired out of a window and killed an eleven-year-old boy named Christopher Sider. Samuel Adams, John's cousin, and the most affected political organizer in Boston, turned the funeral into a demonstration.
SPEAKER_00: And John Adams, who went to it, wrote in his diary that night My eyes never beheld such a funeral. The procession extended
SPEAKER_01: further
SPEAKER_00: than can be well imagined. Then, on the second of March, a soldier of the twenty-nine walked into John Gray's Roadwalk looking for work and was told, in not so friendly terms, what work he could have. Fights between soldiers and roadwalk men went on for the next two days. And three days after that, one of the men from Gray's Roadwalk was among the dead on King Street.
SPEAKER_00: That night on King Street is where the series starts. And from there, we cover the next six years. In March 1770, the argument is between British subjects about what British subjects are owed. By July 1776, it is a war of independence, and a phrase everyone in this story keeps reaching for the rights of Englishmen has turned out to mean very different things, depending on who's saying it.
John Adams Takes The Case
SPEAKER_00: Let's start the morning after the shooting, with a lawyer who takes the case nobody else in Boston will touch.
SPEAKER_00: On the 6th of March, while the town is still counting its debt, a lawyer's merchant named James Forrest comes up the stairs to John Adams' office with, as Adam later remembered it, tears in his eyes. Captain Preston is in Gaul and needs counsel. Every lawyer Forrest has asked has turned him down, and he has been told that if Adams won't take the case, then nobody else will. At this point, Adams is 34. He's a racing man in the Patriot cause. And his cousin Samuel is at that moment BC turning the knight into the Boston Massacre, a name that stakes almost immediately.
SPEAKER_00: Paul Revere will surely have an engraving out showing a neat line of redcoats firing a deliberate volley on Preston's orders into the peaceful crowd. Taking this case is professionally dangerous and politically ruinous. Adams takes it anyway. And years later he set down what he told Forrest that morning. I had no hesitation in answering that counsel ought to be the very last thing that an accused person should want in a free country. That the bar ought, in my opinion, to be independent and impartial at all times and in every circumstance.
SPEAKER_00: Before we go any further, I want to be clear about what kind of men that makes them, as the rest of this act is going to complicate it. Adams believes the soldiers should never have been in Boston to begin with. He believes the policy that put them there is unconstitutional, and he believes with the whole of a very sovereign character that a free people does not hang men without a fair trial, and that if Boston did, it would have handed London the proof that the colonies were exactly the mob the ministry said they were.
SPEAKER_00: The president is tried first in October and acquitted. Nobody can prove he gave the order to fire, and several witnesses say he did not. Then the eight soldiers are tried together, and the prosecutor on the other side of the courtroom is Samuel Quincy, whose younger brother, Josiah, is sitting besides Adams on the defense. In other words, Boston is a small town. Now, the town wants the soldiers convicted, and the jury is drawn from towns around Boston that feel the same way. Adams has to persuade those men to acquit soldiers they despise without asking them to condemn the people of Boston, who are, after all, their own.
SPEAKER_00: So, what Adams does is he finds someone else to condemn. He tells the jury the crowd in King Street was not the people of Boston at all. Here's a passage from his closing argument. The famous phrase in the middle usually gets lifted out on its own, but the sentences around it will tell you what he was doing. We have been entertained with a great variety of phrases to avoid calling this sort of people a mob. Some call them shavers, some call them geniuses. The plain English is, gentlemen, was probably a motley rabble of saucy boys, negroes, and mulattas.
SPEAKER_00: Irish leagues and outstanding jackhtars. And why we should scrubble to call such a set of people a mob, I can't conceive. Unless the name is too respectable for them. Think about who's on that list. There are saucy boys, black men, Irishmen, and foreign sailors. And every one of them is somebody a jury Massachusetts farmers would not count as their own. And then he gives them a ringleader. He calls Addocks a stout mulatto fellow whose very looks were enough to terrify any person. He says Addocks appears to have undertaken to be the hero of the night, to have formed a crowd up in the dock square and marched into King Street with their clubs, and then to have seized a bayonet with one hand and knocked the soldier down with the other.
SPEAKER_00: And, to his mad behavior, Adams tells the jury, the dreadful carnage of a knight is chiefly to be escribed. He follows it with a line that is still quoted in courtrooms today. Facts are stubborn things, and whatever may be our wishes or inclinations, or the dictates of our passions, they cannot alter the state of the facts and evidence, nor is the law less stable than the fact.
SPEAKER_00: Six of the soldiers are acquitted, two of them, Hugh Montgomery and Matthew Kilroy, are convicted of manslaughter. They plead benefit of clergy, an old legal survival that lets a first offender escape the gallows, and in December they are branded on the thumb in open court and released. Before his regiment sailed, Montgomery admitted privately to his lawyer that he was the one who had shouted fire. Adams went to his grave proud of that trial, and he was entitled to be. Three years later, on the anniversary of the shooting, he wrote this in his diary.
SPEAKER_00: The part I took in the defense of Captain Preston and the soldiers procured me anxiety and obliquity enough. It was, however, one of the most gallant, generous, manly, and disinterested actions in my whole life, and one of the best pieces of service I ever render my country. Judgment of death against those soldiers would have been a foul stain upon the country as the executions of the Quakers or witches anciently. Every word of that is true, right? He did a brave and principled thing, and it cost him.
SPEAKER_00: He was also a defense lawyer using the evidence in front of him, and several witnesses did put addicts at the front of the crowd. But the way he used it tells you something. He won by telling twelve white men that the violence came from outsiders, and that the chief outsider was the dead black sailor in the granary. Lawson got to keep his good name, and Addicts got to keep the blank. That is the first time in this series somebody reaches for the rights of Englishmen and gets them, and it's worth noticing who they were for and who paid.
SPEAKER_00: On the very day the soldiers' fire in King Street, 3,000 miles away in the House of Commons, Lord North stood up and proposed repealing almost all of the Townsend duties.
Stubborn Facts And A Convenient Mob
SPEAKER_00: The two pieces of news crossed each other in the Atlantic, and for two years after that, Boston was quiet enough that people thought the crisis was over. However, something else was happening in those years, and it was quieter and much harder to put back.
SPEAKER_00: In June 1772 in London, Lord Mansfield ruled in the case of a man named James Somerset, who had been brought from Virginia to England by his owner and had run away. Mansfield's actual ruling was narrow. He held that no law in England allowed a master to force a slave out of the country to be sold. But what people heard on both sides of the ocean was that the air of England was too free for a slave to breathe, and that was the version that traveled. This ruling reached Boston, and in Boston, the enslaved were reading the newspapers too.
SPEAKER_00: In April of 1773, four men, Peter Besties, Sambo Freeman, Felix Holbrook, and Chester Joey, put their names to a printed letter addressed to the representatives of their town in the Massachusetts legislature. I'm going to give you the opening at length, as every line of it is doing something. Sir, the efforts made by the legislative of this province in their last sessions to free themselves from slavery gave us, who are in that deplorable state, a high degree of satisfaction. We expect great things from men who have made such a noble stand against the designs of their fellow men to enslave them.
SPEAKER_00: We cannot but wish and hope, sir, that you will have the same grand object. We mean civil and religious liberty in view of the next session. The divine spirit of freedom seems to fire every humane breast in this continent.
SPEAKER_00: You see, they're taking the patriots at exactly their word. You call a tax on paper slavery? Wonderful. Here are some people who know what that word means, and they would like to vote on it too. And what they asked for in the letter was modest. They wanted to be allowed one day a week to work for themselves so they could save enough to pay their own passage back to Africa. Unfortunately, the legislature did not act on it, but the letter was printed and read, and the men who wrote it were using the vocabulary of the rights of Englishmen better than most of the Englishmen wear.
SPEAKER_00: And then, at the end of the same year, came the tea.
Tea As Bailout And Breaking Point
SPEAKER_00: The Tea Act of 1773 is a bailout. The East India Company is close to collapse. It had warehouses full of unsold tea, and Parliament lets it ship the tea straight to America through its own chosen agents. The result, and this always surprises people, is that legal tea in Boston is about to be cheaper than smuggled tea. What the colonists object to is the small towns of duty still sitting on it, kept their own purpose to establish that Parliament could tax them, and a monopoly handed to a handful of well-connected consignees.
SPEAKER_00: In Boston, two of those consignees are sons of the governor, Thomas Hutchinson. Three ships come in: the Dartmouth, the Ellianer, and the Beaver. Under customs law, if the duty is not paid within 20 days of the first ship's arrival, the cargo can be seized and landed. And the 20th day is the 16th of December. The Patriots will not let the T be landed, and Hutchinson will not let the ships leave the harbor without paint. That afternoon, several thousand people pack into the old South meeting house and the streets surrounded while the Darmans owners ride out to the governor's country house at Milton to beg for a pass.
SPEAKER_00: He comes back after dark, the answer is no. Within the hour, a hundred or more men, some of their faces blackened with soup and blankets around their shoulders, a thin pretense of being mohawks, go aboard the three ships at Griffin's Wharf. In about three hours, they break open 342 chests and tip something over 90,000 pounds of tea into the harbor. They're careful about it and break nothing else. And one man caught stuffing tea into his coats, it's roughed up and sent home without it. John Adams, the lawyer of Law and Order, wrote in his diary the next morning.
SPEAKER_00: This is the most magnificent movement of all. For its dignity, a majesty, a sublimity, and this last effort of the patriots that I greatly admire. The people should never rise without doing something to be remembered. Something notable and striking. This destruction of the T is so bold, so daring, so firm, intrepid, and inflexible, that it must have so important consequences and so lasting that I cannot but consider it as an epoch in history. This is the same man who called the King Street crowd a rabble three years earlier, remember?
SPEAKER_00: And as far as he was concerned, the difference was discipline. A mob throws eyes at a sentry, whereas a people destroys property in good order and goes home. That distinction mattered enormously to the men running this movement. And you'll see it again.
SPEAKER_00: London's answer comes in the spring, in four acts of parliament that the colonists call the intolerable acts.
Intolerable Acts Unite The Colonies
SPEAKER_00: The port of Boston is closed from the first of June until the tea is paid for. The Massachusetts Charter is effectively rewritten, so that the council will now be appointed by the Crown and town meetings, which are how New England actually governs itself, are limited to one a year without the governor's permission. Officials accused of capital crimes while enforcing the law can be tried in England, and troops can be quartered wherever the governor sees fit. The new governor, by the way, is a soldier named General Thomas Gage, Commander-in-Chief in North America, and he arrives in May with more regiments.
SPEAKER_00: Now, in the same month that the port of Boston is closed, Somerset's case turned up somewhere nobody in London would have expected. In June 1774, a man named Gabriel Jones in Augusta City, Virginia, put an advertisement in the Virginia Gazette for a runaway called Bacchus, and told readers where he thought Bacchus was going. He expected him to track. To get on board some vessel bound for Great Britain from the knowledge he has of the late determination of the Somerset case. Think about what that means.
SPEAKER_00: A planter in the Shenandoah Valley is telling the public that the man he owns has been following a decision of the Court of King's Bench and has drawn his own conclusions about which government was more likely to set him free. In 1774, that is a remarkable thing to admit in print, and Jones was not the only one admitting it. In other words, it seemed as if the colonials were being threatened by the laws in England that could also free their slaves. So the punishment of one colony does what Boston's agitators had never managed.
SPEAKER_00: It frightens the other twelve. In September, delegates from every colony except Georgia meet in Philadelphia, in what becomes the first Continental Congress. On the second day of business, Patrick Henry of Virginia stands up, and according to John Adams' notes on the debate, he tells them The distinctions between Virginians, Pennsylvanians, New Yorkers, and New Englanders are no more. I am not a Virginian, but an American. It's a magnificent line, and it was untrue. They spend the next week fighting about how votes should be counted, whose trade would suffer, and how far to go.
SPEAKER_00: A Pennsylvanian named Joseph Galloway put forward a plan to keep the colonies inside the Empire with an American parliament of their own. It was defeated by a single colony six to five. Remember the name Galloway. He ends this war on the other side. What the Congress did agree on was to boycott the British goods, enforced by committees in every county. Those committees will matter more than anything else, they decide. And they are the first institutions in America that answered to Congress rather than to the king.
SPEAKER_00: In plenty of places, from that winter on, they are the government. And in London, the king had already made up his mind. That November he wrote to his Prime Minister. The New England governments are in a state of rebellion. Blows must decide whether they are to be subjects of this country or independent. In November 1774, almost nobody in America is saying the word independent out loud, and George III already has.
Lexington And Concord Spiral Out
SPEAKER_00: Let me take you to a green in a farming town called Lexington, 11 miles west of Boston, just before sunrise on Wednesday, the 19th of April, 1775. Overnight, General Gage had sent about 700 of his best troops, grenadier and light infantry companies, across the Back Bay with orders to march to the town of Conquer and destroy the militia stores of powder and cannon. It was supposed to be a secret, but the whole of Fosta knew by that time. Two lanterns went up in the steeple of the Old North Church.
SPEAKER_00: Paul Revere and William Dawes rug out by Sephora Rhodes. Revere, for the record, was caught before he reached Concord. The man who actually got the word through was a young doctor named Samuel Crascott, who had been out late courting. On Lexington Common, the town's militia company had been called out by its captain, John Parker. He's a 47-year-old farmer, a veteran of the French and Indian War, and he is dying of tuberculosis. Somewhere around 77 men have answered him. Some of them have been up since 1 in the morning, waiting it out in the tavern beside the green.
SPEAKER_00: One of them is Prince Eastbrook. He's a black man, and he is enslaved, and he is standing on the common that morning with the rest of the company.
SPEAKER_00: The British Light Infantry come up the road at a run and spill onto the common, shouting. A commander, Major John Pitcairn of the Marines, rides forward and orders the militia to lay down their arms and disperse. Here's what Parker swore six days later about what he had decided to do. I order our militia to meet on the common and set Lanxington to consult on what to do and conclude it not to be discovered, or meddle or make with said regular troops, they should approach. Unless they should insult or molest us.
SPEAKER_00: And upon their sudden approach, I immediately order our militia to disperse and not to fire. And Pitcairn's own report says he ordered his men not to fire either, but to surround the militia and the start. Somebody fired. Nobody knows who. And nobody has ever known. It might have been a militiaman behind the wall, or a British officer's pistol, or a nervous private, or a spectator by the tavern. And every side story was the other. What followed was a volley of British officers could not stop. And then a bayonet charge.
SPEAKER_00: When it is over, eight Lexington men are dead, on or near the common. Several of them within sight of their own front doors. Ten are wounded, Prince Eastbrook among them. On the British side, one soldier has a minor wound. The British form up, give three cheers and march on to Concord.
SPEAKER_00: Nobody had planned this morning. That's exactly how it got so dangerous. At Concord, the troops search the town and find very little, as most of the stores have already been moved. They burn some gun carriages, and from the hill above the river, several hundred militia from the surrounding towns see smoke rising and conclude that the town is being burned. They come down towards the North Bridge in good order. The British fire first. Two men from Acton are killed. Captain Isaac Davis and a young private named Abner Hossmer.
SPEAKER_00: The militia fire back with a full volley, without orders from anybody, and for the first time that day, his British soldiers line on the ground. The regulars break and fall back into town. The march back is 18 miles, and it is an absolute nightmare for the British. Militia companies are arriving from every town for 20 miles now, and they don't stand in lines. They fire from behind walls and barns and trees along the road, they fall back, run ahead through the fields, and fire again. By the time the column staggers back into Lexington in the early afternoon, the men are out of ammunition and close to breaking, and the only reason they get home at all is a relief brigade of a thousand men with two cannon under Lord Hugh Percy, which Gage had sent out that morning.
SPEAKER_00: The worst of it is at monotomy, where the fighting goes house to house. By the time the British reach the safety of Charlestown after dark, seventy-three of them are dead, more than a hundred and seventy are wounded, and two dozen are missing. The colonists have lost 49 killed.
SPEAKER_00: Percy rode home the next day, and he clearly had his mind changed. Whoever looks upon them as an irregular mob will find himself much mistaken. You have men among them who know very well what they are about, having been employed as strangers against the Indians and Canadians. This country being much covered with wood and hilly is very advantageous for their method of fighting. Within days, something like fifteen thousand militiamen from four New England colonies have camped in a ring around Boston, and the British army is besieged in the town it came to govern.
SPEAKER_00: Meanwhile, six hundred miles south, and at the very next night, something happens that nobody in Virginia yet connects to Massachusetts, as the news of Lexington is still days away on the post roads. In the small hours of the 21st of April, a party of Royal Marines from a ship in the James River goes quietly into the public powder magazine in Williamsburg, the colonial capital, and carries off fifteen half barrels of gunpowder on the orders of the Royal Governor of Virginia.
Dunmore Threatens Freedom As Fire
SPEAKER_00: His name is John Murray, Fort Earl of Dunmore. Hold on to that name. It's going to matter more than almost anyone else in this episode. Williamsburg wakes up furious and the militia turn out. Patrick Henry marches a company from Hanover County towards the capital. Dunmore ends up paying for the powder to make them go home. But in the middle of the crisis, according to sworn statements from a Williamsburg doctor named William Pasteur, the governor lost his temper and said something the doctor never forgot.
SPEAKER_00: Dunmore swore by the living God, Pasteur testified that if any harm came to the officials involved, or any insult was offered to himself, he would declare freedom to the slaves and reduce the city of Williamsburg to ashes. That threat went round Virginia faster than the news of Lexington did. In those same days, a group of enslaved men came to the governor's palace and offered to take up arms for him, and Dunmore had them told to go about their business.
SPEAKER_00: We are now back in Boston, two months into the siege.
Breed’s Hill And The Cost Of Half Measures
SPEAKER_00: The colonial army does something so provocative that it can only have been half planned. On the night of the 16th of June, about a thousand men under Colonel William Prescott cross into the Charleston Peninsula, directly across the river from Boston, with orders to fortify Bunker Hill. For reasons that are still argued about, they dig in instead on Breed's Hill, which is lower, closer to Boston and much more exposed. Working all night in silence, they throw up an earthwork redoubt about 40 yards on the side.
SPEAKER_00: At first light, a British sailor on the HMS Lively looks across the water and sees a fort that wasn't there at sunset. The lively opens fire, and the rest of the fleet and the batteries from Cops Hill in Boston. The British commanders have a choice. They could land behind the Americans at the narrow neck of the peninsula, cut them off and starve them out. General William Howe decides instead to land at the front, march uphill, and take the position head on. As far as he's concerned, these are farmers in a ditch, and a demonstration of what regular infantry can do will be good for everyone's education.
SPEAKER_01: HEPENA!
SPEAKER_00: Howe lands about 2,200 men in the early afternoon. They form up in lines on the slope. To stop snipers from firing from the houses, the British set Charleston alight with heated shot. And the whole town, about 400 buildings, burns through the afternoon while the battle is fought beside it. Across the water, the rooftops and steeples of Boston are packed with spectators. You'll have heard the famous order: don't fire until you see the whites of their eyes. That's attributed to Prescott and to Israel Potnam.
SPEAKER_00: Versions of it had been given by European generals for decades, but nobody can show that anyone said it at Breed's Hill. What we do know is that the Americans were short of powder and had been told to hold their fire until the last moment. And they did, to great effect. The first British line comes up the hill in heavy kit, through long grass and over fences, and is shot down at 50 yards. It falls back. Howe reforms and sends them up again, and it happens again. Officers are hit at an extraordinary rate, and Howe himself at the front has every member of his personal staff killed or wounded around him.
SPEAKER_00: The third assault goes up with packs off and bayonets fixed, and this time it reaches the redoubt. And this time the Americans are almost out of powder. They throw stones and swing their muskets like clubs, and then they break and run back across the neck. And it is in that retreat that the British finally do most of their killing. Among the men killed in the redoubt is Dr. Joseph Warren, president of the Massachusetts Provincial Congress and the most popular man in Boston, who had insisted on fighting as a volunteer.
SPEAKER_00: Among the British dead is Major John Pitcairn, the officer who wrote onto Lexington Common. The next day, from the farm at Braintree, where she and her seven-year-old son had climbed the hill to watch the smoke over Charleston, Abigail Adams wrote to her husband in Philadelphia. Today, perhaps the decisive day is come on which the fate of America depends. A bursting heart must find Ben at my pen. I have just heard that our dear friend Dr. Warren is no more, but felt gloriously fighting for his country.
SPEAKER_00: Saying better to die honorably in the field than ignominiously hang upon the gallows. Great is our loss. The British took the hill, and it cost them over a thousand casualties, two hundred and twenty-six of them killed, roughly two thousand four hundred men engaged. That is nearly one man in two. The Americans lost about four hundred and fifty. Henry Clinton, who'd crossed over to help during the battle, wrote in his notes that it was a dearly bought victory, and that another such would have ruined them.
SPEAKER_00: And Gage, who had led the advance guard on Monga twenty years earlier and knew these colonies from the Seven Years War, rode home to London a week later, and he did not dress it up. This people show a spirit and conduct against us they never showed against the French, and everybody has judged of them from their former appearance and behavior when joined with the king's forces in the last war, which has led many into great mistakes. They are now spirited up by rage and enthusiasm as great as ever a people were possessed of, and you must proceed in earnest or give the business up.
SPEAKER_00: A small body acting in one spot will not avail. You must have large armies, making diversions of different sides to divide their forces. The loss we have sustained is greater than we can bear. Proceed in earnest, he says, or give the business up. That's the lesson of Breed's Hill, written down by a man who paid for it. The twenty-sixth of June seventeen seventy-five. Either send an army big enough to conquer the continent or just make peace. However, for the next eight years, Britain does neither of the things.
SPEAKER_00: It sends armies large enough to win battles, but never large enough to rule the country. And it offers terms generous enough to annoy its own supporters, but never generous enough to end the war. In other words, it spends eight years on half measures. The age was recalled at autumn, and the man who has seen it most clearly was the first one to say now. The second Continental Congress has adopted the army outside of Boston as its own, and two days before it breeds hill, has given command of it to a Virginian who turned on to the sessions in uniform.
SPEAKER_00: He arrives at Cambridge in early July, and we'll spend the whole of our next episode with him.
SPEAKER_00: The king, for his part, rejects the Congress's last petition for reconciliation without reading it, and in August formally proclaims the colonies in open rebellion. Something else was settled that autumn, quietly, in a council of war.
Washington’s Army Draws A Color Line
SPEAKER_00: There are black soldiers in the army around Boston. There were black men at Lansington and at the Norbridge on O'Breeds Hill. A free black man named Peter Salem fought in the redoubt and tradition, which may or may not be right, says he fired the shot that killed Pitcairn. Even so, in early October, Washington's generals vote to enlist no more enslaved men at all, and by a majority to enlist no free black men either. And on the 12th of November, he goes into general orders. Neither Negroes, boys unable to bear arms, nor old men unfit to endure the fatigues of the campaign are to be enlisted.
SPEAKER_00: Three weeks after that order, 14 American officers, Colonel William Prescott among them, signed a petition to the Massachusetts legislature about a black soldier named Salem Poor, who had bought his own freedom eight years earlier and who had fought on Breeds Hill, in a way they felt deserved notice. They told the legislature that they would only beg leave to say that in the person of that said Negro centers a brave and gallant soldier. By the autumn of 1775, Lord Dunmore is a governor without a capital.
SPEAKER_00: He fled Williamsburg in June for a warship in the York River, and since then he has been running what is left of Royal Government in Virginia from a small fleet off of Norfolk, with a few hundred soldiers of the 14th Regiment, some loyalist volunteers, and a growing conviction that the Patriots of Virginia have one great weakness. Roughly two in every five people in Virginia are enslaved, and Dunmore knows exactly what the planters are afraid of, because he owns enslaved people himself.
Dunmore’s Proclamation Changes Virginia
SPEAKER_00: On the 7th of November 1775, aboard a merchant ship anchored off of Norfolk, he signs a proclamation declaring martial law in the colony. Most of it is what you'd expect.
SPEAKER_00: And then there is one sentence that changes the war in Virginia. And I do hereby further declare all indented servants, negroes and others, appertaining to rebels, free that are able and willing to bear arms, they joining his majesty's troops as soon as may be, for the more speedily reducing this colony to a proper sense of their duty to his majesty's crown and dignity. I want to go through that slowly with you, as nearly every phrase of it is a qualification. When it says appertaining to rebels, it means the enslaved people of loyal masters stay enslaved.
SPEAKER_00: When it says able and willing to bear arms, it means this is a recruiting order, and it's for men. And when it says for the more speedily reducing this colony, it tells you the purpose is to win this war, and that freedom is the price Dunmore is prepared to pay for soldiers. Seven months earlier, remember, he had turned enslaved volunteers away from his own door. It is a document of an opportunist, written by a slaveholder, and he frees nobody who doesn't first get past the patrols, across the river and out to the ships.
SPEAKER_00: On paper, it is a narrow and cynical thing. It is also the largest offer of freedom made to enslaved people by anyone, on either side, in the whole of British American history up to that point. And the people it was addressed to read it more generously than what he wrote it. Here's how it landed on one plantation on the Potomac. A certain Mount Vernon. George Washington is in Cambridge commanding the army. Discussion Lund Washington is managing Mount Vernon and his doctor, and writes to him every week or so about the crop and the building work and the household.
SPEAKER_00: In early December, between the business, erupted. this. Our Gunmore has at length published his much-dreaded proclamation, declare freedom to all indented servants and slaves, The cost of product, that will be fair to this magic standard, be able to bear art. What effect it will have upon those stored items and effects? I think if there was no white determinants in this standard, it could be under no apprehension about display. However, I am determined that if any of them made any confusion to make an example.
SPEAKER_00: of. Sears, who is at work here, says there is not a man often but would leave us. They believe they can make their escape, Tom Spears accepted, and yet they have no fault to find. Liberty is sweet. Now I'll be honest. I read that letter maybe a dozen times and I keep landing on different parts of it. The first is the threat that he'll make an example of anyone who causes trouble. Then it's the self-deception. That they have no fault to find. But the part I can't get past is the last three words.
SPEAKER_00: Liberty is sweet. He's managing the estate of the commander of the army fighting for ostensibly liberty. He's telling him that everyone they own would run if they could. And he understands why. Just doesn't follow the thought any further than that.
Canoes In The Dark And Ethiopian Regiment
SPEAKER_00: They went in canoes and stolen boats down the creek of the tide water and on foot through the marshes at night, in ones and twos and sometimes whole families, with women and children among them, whatever the proclamation said about bearing arms. They made for the British ships off of Norfolk and the camps along the Elizabeth River. Within a few weeks, several hundred had reached Dunmore. By the spring, they were somewhere close to a thousand, with some estimates putting it much higher. Virginia's Patriots answered with everything they had.
SPEAKER_00: The Virginia Gazette ran warnings that Dunmore was the slaveholder lying to them, and that anyone who went with him would be sold off to a sugar island in the West Indies to pay for the war. Given everything we know about what the West Indies did to people, this was the most frightening thing you could say to an enslaved Virginia. In December, the Virginia Convention declared that any enslaved person taken in arms with Dunmore would be put to death without benefit of clergy. Those who came back within 10 days would be pardoned.
SPEAKER_00: It didn't stop it. They kept coming. Dunmore formed the men into a unit and called it the Ethiopian Regiment. According to a report printed that winter, they went into the field with the words Liberty to Slays across their uniforms. In Philadelphia, the Congress was treating the proclamation too. On the 8th of December, Edward Rutland of South Carolina wrote to a friend that Dunworth's proclamation would do more to work an eternal separation between Britain and the colonies than anything else that could possibly have been thought of.
SPEAKER_00: And he had a point. In 1775, plenty of Southern planters were still hoping for a settlement in London. And after November, a good many of them concluded that a government willing to arm their slaves was a government they could no longer live under. Some historians go further and argue that protecting slavery was one of the central motives for independence in this house. However, that argument can be pushed too far, and I want to be careful with it. The revolution started in Massachusetts over a close harbor, a written charter and soldiers in the streets, and nobody on Lexington Common was thinking about Dunmore.
SPEAKER_00: A great many patriots believed sincerely in the principles they were fighting for, and within a few years, those same principles would push Vermont, Pennsylvania, and Massachusetts to start dismantling slavery inside their own borders. So the spark was struck in New England over self-government, and in Virginia, the fear of black freedom was the accelerant that helped settle whether to join or stay. On the morning of December 10th, Dunmore throws his army at a Virginia position across a causeway at a place called Great Bridge.
Great Bridge Defeat And Washington Panics
SPEAKER_00: The grenadiers of the 14th lead the assault straight down the causeway into the prepared defenses, and they are slaughtered. And their captain, Charles Fortas, dies within yards of the Virginia breastwork. Dunmore's black soldiers are there in support, and the attack is a disaster. It was a very small battle, and it effectively ended Dunmore's hopes of holding the mainland. Even so, Washington understood exactly what he was looking at. The day after Christmas, he wrote from Cambridge to Richard Henry Lee of Virginia.
SPEAKER_00: If, my dear sir, that man is not crushed before the spring, he will become the most formidable enemy America has. His strength will increase as a snowball by rolling faster. If some expedient cannot be hit upon to convince the slaves and servants of the impotency of his designs. Washington is calling him the most formidable enemy America has, and he's saying it in December of 1775. At that moment he's facing a British army of tens of thousands, and the largest navy in the world, and the full weight of the Empire.
SPEAKER_00: And the enemy he's most afraid of is the governor on a ship with a few hundred men. What frightens him is who those men are, and how many more could follow. Four days later, on the 13th of December, he quietly reverses the November order and allows free black men who had already served to re-enlist. And the Congress confirms it in January.
Norfolk Burns Then Smallpox Follows
SPEAKER_00: On New Year's Day, 1776, Dunmore ships onboarded Norfolk. Between his guns and the Patriot troops, who then put most of the town to the torch to deny it to him, the largest town in Virginia burned to the ground. After that, he had nowhere left on the mainland. In the end, though, defeated Dunmore was smallpox.
SPEAKER_00: Most people raised in Africa or on a remote Virginia plantation had never been exposed to it. And in the crowded ships and camps of Dunmore's fleet that winter, it found thousands of people with no protection at all. Dunmore tried to inoculate them, but it wasn't enough. By late May 1776, the fleet, which is nearly a hundred vessels by now, has fallen back to Gwynes Island at the mouth of the Rappahannock, and the camp there is as much a hospital as it is a fort. Along with the smallpox came what the British captains called an epidemic fever, and the two together were killing Dunmore's black recruits faster than the Virginians ever had.
SPEAKER_00: At the end of June, Dunmore wrote to London. Had it not been for this horrid disorder, I should have had two thousand blacks with whom I should have no doubt been penetrating into the heart of this colony.
SPEAKER_00: Let me take you to two places on the same day. In New York, on the 9th of July 1776, the brigades of the Continental Army are formed up on their parade ground at 6 in the evening. And by Washington's order, a document adopted by the Congress of Philadelphia the week before is read out loud to them. That night, the crowd goes to Bowling Green and pulls down the gilded lead statue of George III on horseback, and the lead will be melted into muskets. Among the grievances against the king listed in the document is this one.
SPEAKER_00: He has excited domestic insurrection among us. That grievance is about Dunmore, and the insurrection it means is the people in the canoes. If you heard Original Sin in our Civil War series, you know how the men in Philadelphia went on to handle that contradiction on paper, and I'd point you there for it. This series is going to follow what happened off the paper. On the same day, 300 miles south, Virginian artillery opens fire across a narrow channel into Gwenn's Island. By the next day, Dunmore has evacuated, and when the Virginians cross over, they find what he has left behind.
SPEAKER_00: There are hundreds of graves. Many of the sick are still lying where they were left. And there are remains of the brush huts of a small party camp. The Virginian descent reports that near five hundred souls have died there. The survivors, about 300 of them, sailed with Dunmore out of Chesapeake into August and out of Virginia for good. Where they end up is a story we'll come back to in a later series.
SPEAKER_00: Every person in this episode reaches for the same inheritance.
Rights Claimed Then Paid For
SPEAKER_00: John Adams reaches for trial by jury and the right of an accused man to counsel, and he wins them for eight soldiers by making a dead sailor from out of town carry the blame. The man who wrote to the Massachusetts legislature in 1773 reach for the language of liberty the legislature had been using for a decade. They use it better. Bacchus reaches for a judgment of the court of King's Bench, and Dunmore reaches for freedom as a weapon after turning it away when it was offered to him for free. Then there's the people on the boats.
SPEAKER_00: Been thinking about how to describe what they did without making it into something it wasn't. We're not making a statement about the British Constitution. Most of them had never been offered either side's version of the rights of Englishmen. And they were under no illusions about Dunmore. They knew he owned people, and the Gazette made sure they knew he might sell them. What they were doing, though, was waiting two sets of white men's promises against each other in the dark, with their lives and their children's lives at the stake, and judging which one was more likely to be kept.
SPEAKER_00: That's a hard calculation. Many of them got it wrong, and smallpox took hundreds of the ones who got it right. But it's a calculation made by people, and it deserves to be remembered as one rather than as a footnote to someone else's declaration. By the time this war ends, something like 20,000 enslaved people will have made the same calculation and gone over to the British. Some of them will fight, and some of them will be betrayed. A few thousand will sell out of New York in 1783 with their names written in a ledger, and they'll go on to Nova Scotia, and some of them from there to Africa, carrying the surnames of the men they had escaped from.
SPEAKER_00: We'll meet some of them later in the series.
SPEAKER_00: In six years, a dispute about tea duties and town meetings has become a war that nobody on Lexington Common meant to start. The thirteen clocks have struck together for the first time. And Britain has been told in writing by its own commander to fight in earnest or give up. It is going to try to fight in earnest. And for the next eighteen months, it is going to win almost every battle it fights.
Next Time The Army Refuses To Die
SPEAKER_00: Next time, on Double Helix, by Christmas 1776, the Continental Army has been driven out of New York and across New Jersey, and most of what's left of it is due to go home on New Year's Day. We look at an army that spends two years losing and refuses to disappear, at a commander whose own Congress starts to wonder if they picked the wrong man, and at the strange arithmetic at which the battle that really matters is fought 200 miles away by two generals who can't stand each other. Until then, thank you for listening.
SPEAKER_00: We will see you soon.
Podbean